Gou Jiesong, Zhu Jing
Institute of Western China Economic Research, Southwestern University of Finance and Economics, Chengdu, Sichuan, China.
PLoS One. 2025 Sep 5;20(9):e0331476. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0331476. eCollection 2025.
Based on the establishment data of provincial-provincial, city-city, provincial-city, city-provincial Hometown Chambers of Commerce (HCCs) in China by the end of 2022, this paper combines social network analysis and exponential random graph model to explore network spatial patterns and determinants of China's HCCs. Findings indicate that: 1) Point degree centrality in eastern China is high, but spatial patterns vary across network types: provincial-provincial and provincial-city types exhibit a "rhombus-net" pattern, the city-city type follows a "small-ring-line" structure, and the city-provincial type forms a "large-ring-net" type. Guangdong, Fujian, Zhejiang, Jiangxi, and Shandong constitute core areas of China's HCC network, and provincial-provincial and city-city types mainly flow within the core area and from core to periphery, while provincial-city and city-provincial types flow mutually between core and periphery areas. 2) Stronger government intervention and earlier HCC connections significantly inhibit both provincial-provincial and city-city HCC establishment. However, this inhibitory effect is not statistically significant for provincial-city and city-provincial types. Only city-city HCCs exhibit economic sensitivity, with less-developed origin cities favoring stronger operation cities, while other HCC types remain economically neutral. Road, dialect, and urban cluster distances significantly affect HCC establishment at the city-level place of operation but show no significant impact on the provincial-level place of operation. This research not only expands the theoretical perspective on the spatial study of social organizations but also provides scientific evidence for breaking down regional market fragmentation and optimizing cross-regional governance systems.
基于截至2022年底中国省级-省级、市级-市级、省级-市级、市级-省级同乡商会的设立数据,本文结合社会网络分析和指数随机图模型,探讨中国同乡商会的网络空间格局及其影响因素。研究结果表明:1)中国东部地区的点度中心性较高,但不同网络类型的空间格局存在差异:省级-省级和省级-市级类型呈现“菱形网络”格局,市级-市级类型呈“小环线”结构,市级-省级类型则形成“大环线网络”类型。广东、福建、浙江、江西和山东构成了中国同乡商会网络的核心区域,省级-省级和市级-市级类型主要在核心区域内流动以及从核心流向周边,而省级-市级和市级-省级类型则在核心区域与周边区域之间相互流动。2)更强的政府干预和更早建立的同乡商会联系显著抑制省级-省级和市级-市级同乡商会的设立。然而,这种抑制作用在省级-市级和市级-省级类型中在统计上并不显著。只有市级-市级同乡商会表现出经济敏感性,经济欠发达的原籍城市倾向于经济更强的运营城市,而其他同乡商会类型在经济上保持中立。道路、方言和城市群距离对市级运营地的同乡商会设立有显著影响,但对省级运营地没有显著影响。本研究不仅拓展了社会组织空间研究的理论视角,还为打破区域市场分割和优化跨区域治理体系提供了科学依据。