Paymard Mohammadamin, Naderian Homayoun, Hassani Bafrani Hassan, Azami Tameh Abolfazl, Mirsafi Niasar Mohammadali, Rahimi Habibollah, Hosseini Hanieh Sadat, Rafat Ali
Anatomical Sciences Research Center, Institute for Basic Sciences, Kashan University of Medical Sciences, Kashan, Iran.
Department of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, School of Public Health, Kashan University of Medical Sciences, Kashan, Iran.
Surg Radiol Anat. 2025 Sep 5;47(1):199. doi: 10.1007/s00276-025-03704-x.
Medical students primarily learn anatomy through lectures and atlases. Since mastering anatomy requires spatial visualization, dissection of cadavers has traditionally been regarded as the most effective approach in this discipline. Unfortunately, there are many drawbacks to this method, including accessibility issues. Nowadays, the use of 3D printing and other advanced technologies as educational tools in anatomy courses has been on the rise and they can play an extremely beneficial role in this regard. This study sought to evaluate the effectiveness of 3D printed anatomical models for student education.
MATERIALS & METHODS: The selected anatomical models were scanned using a 3D scanner, taking into account their 3D features and their application in hands-on learning settings. Minor modifications were made to the scanned files with the help of computer software before they were printed. Ultimately, the models were assessed by faculty members and students from different disciplines.
Once the models were prepared, they were given to various groups, including professors, medical students, MSc anatomy students, surgery residents, and BSc radiology students for evaluation. The opinions of these groups were then compared across two sets of models, and their assessments were analyzed in various cases. The feedback from four groups of students i.e. medical students, MSc anatomy students, surgery residents, and BSc radiology students indicated a notable contrast with the feedback from the professors' group.
3D printed models serve as valuable resources for teaching and learning anatomy from diverse viewpoints, catering to learners at different levels of study. Nevertheless, despite the usefulness of 3D models, anatomy professors believe that natural specimens associated with cadavers remain the most essential teaching resource for anatomy.
医学生主要通过讲座和图谱学习解剖学。由于掌握解剖学需要空间可视化能力,传统上尸体解剖被视为该学科最有效的方法。不幸的是,这种方法存在许多缺点,包括可及性问题。如今,3D打印和其他先进技术作为解剖学课程的教育工具的使用正在增加,并且它们在这方面可以发挥极其有益的作用。本研究旨在评估3D打印解剖模型对学生教育的有效性。
考虑所选解剖模型的3D特征及其在实践学习环境中的应用,使用3D扫描仪对其进行扫描。在打印之前,借助计算机软件对扫描文件进行了微小修改。最终,由来自不同学科的教员和学生对模型进行评估。
模型准备好后,将其分发给包括教授、医学生、解剖学硕士学生、外科住院医师和放射学理学学士学生在内的各个小组进行评估。然后在两组模型之间比较这些小组的意见,并在各种情况下分析他们的评估。医学生、解剖学硕士学生、外科住院医师和放射学理学学士学生这四组学生的反馈与教授组的反馈形成了显著对比。
3D打印模型是从不同视角教授和学习解剖学的宝贵资源,适合不同学习水平的学习者。然而,尽管3D模型有用,但解剖学教授认为与尸体相关的天然标本仍然是解剖学最重要的教学资源。