Nlashwa Garebue D, Sinvula Morrison, Setso Setso O, Miller Wallace, Lesiamang Molatedi, Maboreke Tashinga, Pitcher Richard D
Division of Radiodiagnosis, Department of Medical Imaging and Clinical Oncology, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Stellenbosch University, Cape Town, South Africa.
Ministry of Health Botswana, Gaborone, Botswana.
J Coll Med S Afr. 2024 Sep 26;2(1):87. doi: 10.4102/jcmsa.v2i1.87. eCollection 2024.
The United Nations encourages national audits of diagnostic imaging equipment and personnel. The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that 20 X-ray and ultrasound units per million people will meet 90% of global imaging needs. This study assessed registered diagnostic imaging resources in Botswana, a high middle-income, sparsely populated African country.
Details of registered diagnostic imaging equipment and personnel were extracted from the Botswana Radiation Protection Inspectorate and the Botswana Health Professions Council databases and stratified by imaging modality, professional category, and by geographical region and healthcare sector. Findings were presented as absolute numbers and resources per million people.
Botswana has 130 diagnostic imaging equipment units. General radiography (GR) ( = 79) 60%, mammography ( = 15; 12%), fluoroscopy ( = 13; 10%), computed tomography ( = 13; 10%), magnetic resonance ( = 6; 5%), digital subtraction angiography ( = 3; 2%) and radioisotope ( = 1; 0.7%). General radiography is the only modality where overall public sector resources ( = 44/79, 56%) exceed those of the private sector. Overall GR meet WHO guidelines, while it exceeded WHO guidelines (42-63 units/106 people) in most sparsely populated districts. There are 171 registered radiation workers; 88% ( = 152), radiographers, 9% ( = 15) radiologists and 2% ( = 4) medical physicists. Fifty three per cent of radiographers ( = 80) and 20% of radiologists ( = 3) work in the public sector.
This study provides novel insights into the provision of radiological resources to sparsely populated rural communities.
The study demonstrates a comprehensive analysis of Radiological resources in an upper-middle-income country in Africa, highlighting important data for medium/long term planning towards achieving an equitable imaging access.
联合国鼓励各国对诊断成像设备和人员进行审计。世界卫生组织(WHO)估计,每百万人拥有20台X光和超声设备将满足全球90%的成像需求。本研究评估了博茨瓦纳(一个中高收入、人口稀少的非洲国家)已注册的诊断成像资源。
从博茨瓦纳辐射防护检查局和博茨瓦纳卫生专业人员委员会数据库中提取已注册的诊断成像设备和人员的详细信息,并按成像方式、专业类别、地理区域和医疗保健部门进行分层。研究结果以绝对数字和每百万人的资源数呈现。
博茨瓦纳有130台诊断成像设备。普通放射摄影(GR)(=79台,占60%)、乳腺摄影(=15台,占12%)、透视(=13台,占10%)、计算机断层扫描(=13台,占10%)、磁共振成像(=6台,占5%)、数字减影血管造影(=3台,占2%)和放射性同位素成像(=1台,占0.7%)。普通放射摄影是唯一公共部门总体资源(=44/79,占56%)超过私营部门的成像方式。总体而言,普通放射摄影符合WHO指南,而在大多数人口稀少的地区,其超过了WHO指南(42 - 63台/106人)。有171名注册放射工作人员;88%(=152人)为放射技师,9%(=15人)为放射科医生,2%(=4人)为医学物理学家。53%的放射技师(=80人)和20%的放射科医生(=3人)在公共部门工作。
本研究为向人口稀少的农村社区提供放射资源提供了新的见解。
该研究展示了对非洲一个中高收入国家放射资源的全面分析,突出了实现公平成像获取的中长期规划的重要数据。