Mushtaq Muhammad, Majeed Amir A, Sultan Saher, Yasmeen Rehana, Sharifullah Faryal, Khattak Yasir Rehman, Shah Nasar, Ahmad Iftikhar
Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Hayatabad Medical Complex, Peshawar, Pakistan.
Oral Medicine, Dijlah University, Baghdad, Iraq.
Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2025 Sep 20;29(1):157. doi: 10.1007/s10006-025-01455-y.
Ameloblastoma (AB) are aggressive odontogenic tumors, often treated with wide marginal resection and concurrent reconstruction. Extended total temporomandibular joint replacement (eTMJR) prosthesis is a viable treatment option for reconstruction of large defects caused by resection of AB tumors. The objective of this study was to systematically review the utilization and effectiveness of eTMJR prosthesis in treating patients with AB tumors.
A detail search in Web of Science, Medline/PubMed, Google Scholar and Embase identified studies reporting AB patients who underwent implantation of eTMJR prosthesis. Studies reporting the use of eTMJR prosthesis in the management of AB tumors were eligible, with no restriction of the study type, language or year of publication and patient's demographics. Quality assessment of the selected case reports and case series was carried out with the 13 Domains (30 Items) of the CARE checklist, using a scoring scale of "0" (No/ non-adherence), "1" (Yes/ adherence) and "2" (unclear). The completeness of reporting (COR) score was determined as the ratio of "yes" responses to "total" (i.e., yes + no + unclear) responses.
A total of 27 studies were selected for analysis, including 15 case reports, 06 case series and 06 retrospective cohort studies. These studies presented 41 patients of AB who received eTMJR prosthesis. The patients' mean age was 37.8 ± 14.9 (range: 14-72, median: 36) years, whereas the mean follow-up period was 19.7 ± 20.3 (range: 1-84, median 12) months. The majority of studies did not document all clinically relevant data regarding patient clinical presentation, surgical procedures, long-term follow-up and post-operative complications. The mean ± SD (range, median) COR score for all case reports/ series was 61.7 ± 23.5 (4.0-100, 64.0) %.
The use of eTMJR prosthesis in the management of AB tumors has demonstrated promising treatment outcome in case reports/ series. However, large cohort randomized controlled trials are essential to establish their therapeutic efficacy.
成釉细胞瘤(AB)是侵袭性牙源性肿瘤,常采用广泛边缘切除并同期重建治疗。扩大全颞下颌关节置换(eTMJR)假体是重建AB肿瘤切除所致大缺损的一种可行治疗选择。本研究的目的是系统评价eTMJR假体在治疗AB肿瘤患者中的应用及效果。
在Web of Science、Medline/PubMed、谷歌学术和Embase中进行详细检索,以确定报告接受eTMJR假体植入的AB患者的研究。报告在AB肿瘤管理中使用eTMJR假体的研究符合条件,对研究类型、语言、发表年份和患者人口统计学无限制。使用CARE检查表的13个领域(30项)对所选病例报告和病例系列进行质量评估,评分标准为“0”(否/未遵守)、“1”(是/遵守)和“2”(不清楚)。报告完整性(COR)得分确定为“是”回答与“总数”(即“是”+“否”+“不清楚”)回答的比率。
共选择27项研究进行分析,包括15项病例报告、6项病例系列和6项回顾性队列研究。这些研究介绍了41例接受eTMJR假体的AB患者。患者的平均年龄为37.8±14.9(范围:14 - 72岁,中位数:36岁),而平均随访期为19.7±20.3(范围:1 - 84个月,中位数12个月)。大多数研究未记录所有与患者临床表现、手术程序、长期随访和术后并发症相关的临床数据。所有病例报告/系列的平均±标准差(范围,中位数)COR得分为61.7±23.5(4.0 - 100,64.0)%。
在病例报告/系列中,eTMJR假体在AB肿瘤管理中的应用已显示出有前景的治疗结果。然而,大型队列随机对照试验对于确定其治疗效果至关重要。