Kurobe Masataka, Takahashi Yuki, Kado Naoki, Suzuki Toshiaki
Graduate School of Health Sciences, Graduate School of Kansai University of Health Sciences, Osaka, JPN.
Department of Physical Therapy, Kobe College of Rehabilitation and Health, Kobe, JPN.
Cureus. 2025 Aug 20;17(8):e90618. doi: 10.7759/cureus.90618. eCollection 2025 Aug.
Introduction F-waves are compound muscle action potentials generated by the antidromic activation of alpha motor neuron axons and the backfiring of anterior horn cells in response to electrical stimulation. Several F-wave parameters are used to assess the state of alpha motor neurons. Previous studies have demonstrated that repetitive thumb movements can decrease the F/M amplitude ratio in the abductor pollicis brevis muscle of healthy individuals. This suggests that repetitive movements may be a practical and accessible self-training method for alleviating muscle hypertonia. However, it remains unclear whether similar effects occur in the quadriceps femoris muscle following repetitive knee joint movement. Furthermore, the speed of movement may influence F-wave responses. This study aimed to investigate the effects of repetitive knee joint movements at different speeds on the excitability of anterior horn cells, as assessed by F-waves recorded from the vastus lateralis (VL) muscle before and after the movements. Methods Eighteen healthy adults participated in the study. F-waves were recorded from the VL muscle before, immediately after, and four and eight minutes after each task. In the 1 Hz trial, participants performed repetitive knee joint flexion and extension in synchrony with a 1 Hz auditory cue; in the 2 Hz trial, they moved in time with a 2 Hz cue. In the control trial, participants remained at rest. For F-wave recordings, the cathode of the stimulation electrode was placed at the distal one-fifth point along the line connecting the greater trochanter and the superolateral margin of the patella, with the anode placed at the distal one-fifth point along the line connecting the greater trochanter and the lateral joint space of the knee. The cathode of the recording electrode was positioned at the midpoint between the cathode of the stimulating electrode and the superior lateral border of the patella, and the anode was placed at the patella. The ground electrode was positioned on the anterior surface of the lower leg. Electrical stimulation was delivered at 1.2 times the intensity required to evoke the maximal M-wave amplitude, with a duration of 0.2 ms, a frequency of 0.3 Hz, and a number of stimuli of 60. The bandwidth filter was set between 20 and 3,000 Hz. Outcome measures included M-wave amplitude, F-wave persistence, and the F/M amplitude ratio. Since the Shapiro-Wilk test indicated non-normality, an aligned rank transformation was applied, followed by two-way repeated-measures ANOVA. Results There were no significant changes in the outcomes before or after repetitive knee movements. Additionally, movement speed did not affect the outcomes. Conclusions Unlike a previous report showing decreased excitability of anterior horn cells that innervate the abductor pollicis brevis following repetitive thumb movements, our study found no changes in VL excitability after repetitive knee movements performed at different speeds. These results imply that the modulation of anterior horn cell excitability by repetitive movements depends on the body part involved.
引言
F波是由α运动神经元轴突的逆向激活和前角细胞对电刺激的回返放电所产生的复合肌肉动作电位。几个F波参数用于评估α运动神经元的状态。先前的研究表明,重复的拇指运动可降低健康个体拇短展肌的F/M波幅比值。这表明重复运动可能是一种实用且易于实施的自我训练方法,用于缓解肌肉张力亢进。然而,尚不清楚重复膝关节运动后股四头肌是否会出现类似的效果。此外,运动速度可能会影响F波反应。本研究旨在通过记录运动前后股外侧肌(VL)的F波,探讨不同速度的重复膝关节运动对前角细胞兴奋性的影响。
方法
18名健康成年人参与了本研究。在每个任务之前、之后立即以及之后4分钟和8分钟记录VL肌肉的F波。在1Hz试验中,参与者与1Hz听觉提示同步进行重复的膝关节屈伸;在2Hz试验中,他们与2Hz提示同步运动。在对照试验中,参与者保持静止。对于F波记录,刺激电极的阴极置于连接大转子和髌骨上外侧缘的线的远端五分之一处,阳极置于连接大转子和膝关节外侧关节间隙的线的远端五分之一处。记录电极的阴极位于刺激电极阴极和髌骨上外侧缘中点,阳极置于髌骨处。接地电极置于小腿前表面。以诱发最大M波幅所需强度的1.2倍进行电刺激,持续时间为0.2ms,频率为0.3Hz,刺激次数为60次。带宽滤波器设置在20至3000Hz之间。观察指标包括M波幅、F波出现率和F/M波幅比值。由于Shapiro-Wilk检验表明数据不服从正态分布,因此应用秩和转换,随后进行双向重复测量方差分析。
结果
重复膝关节运动前后各项指标均无显著变化。此外,运动速度对各项指标也无影响。
结论
与先前报道的重复拇指运动后支配拇短展肌的前角细胞兴奋性降低不同,我们的研究发现,不同速度的重复膝关节运动后VL的兴奋性没有变化。这些结果表明,重复运动对前角细胞兴奋性的调节取决于所涉及的身体部位。