Pachebat Nicolas, Mcheik Jiad N, Fieux Maxime, Favier Valentin, Binet Aurélien, Dufour Xavier, Carsuzaa Florent
Service d'ORL et Chirurgie Cervico-Faciale, Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Poitiers, 2 Rue de la Milétrie, F-86000 Poitiers, France.
Faculté de Médecine, Université de Poitiers, F-86000 Poitiers, France.
J Pers Med. 2025 Sep 1;15(9):403. doi: 10.3390/jpm15090403.
: Cleft lip and/or palate (CLP) is frequently associated with persistent nasal obstruction, often due to structural deformities unaddressed by primary surgical repair. While subjective assessment tools are commonly used to evaluate nasal patency, they underestimate functional impairment, particularly nasal valve collapse. This study aims to objectively evaluate nasal obstruction and identify its anatomical causes in CLP patients after primary rhinoplasty. : We conducted an observational study involving 21 children aged 8-16 with CLP who had undergone primary cheilorhinoplasty but not secondary nasal surgery. Each participant underwent clinical evaluation, nasal endoscopy, acoustic rhinometry, and active anterior rhinomanometry (AAR), both before and after nasal decongestion. The Nasal Obstruction Symptom Evaluation (NOSE) scale was used to assess subjective symptoms. Obstructive sites were diagnosed based on established criteria combining endoscopic and functional findings. : Objective nasal obstruction was identified in 80.9% of patients, with nasal valve collapse observed in 66.7%, most commonly among unilateral and bilateral CLP subtypes. External nasal valve collapse was the predominant form (57.1%), followed by internal valve involvement (38.1%). Notably, the NOSE score did not reliably correlate with the AAR results, underlining the limitations of subjective assessment tools. Structural anomalies such as septal deviation (52.5%) and turbinate hypertrophy (23.8%) were also prevalent. : This study highlights nasal valve collapse as a major, underrecognized contributor to persistent nasal obstruction in CLP patients after primary repair. Objective assessment methods like AAR and targeted endoscopy should be routinely integrated into secondary rhinoplasty planning. These findings advocate for a personalized approach to secondary nasal reconstruction in CLP patients, integrating objective functional data into surgical planning. Such strategies align with personalized medicine principles by tailoring interventions to individual anatomical and physiological characteristics.
唇腭裂(CLP)常伴有持续性鼻阻塞,这通常是由于初次手术修复未能解决的结构畸形所致。虽然主观评估工具常用于评估鼻通畅度,但它们会低估功能损害,尤其是鼻瓣膜塌陷。本研究旨在客观评估唇腭裂患者初次鼻整形术后的鼻阻塞情况,并确定其解剖学原因。
我们进行了一项观察性研究,纳入了21名年龄在8至16岁之间的唇腭裂儿童,这些儿童均接受了初次唇鼻整形术,但未进行二次鼻手术。每位参与者在鼻腔减充血前后均接受了临床评估、鼻内镜检查、鼻声反射测量和主动前鼻测压(AAR)。使用鼻阻塞症状评估(NOSE)量表来评估主观症状。根据结合内镜和功能检查结果的既定标准诊断阻塞部位。
80.9%的患者存在客观鼻阻塞,66.7%观察到鼻瓣膜塌陷,最常见于单侧和双侧唇腭裂亚型。鼻外瓣膜塌陷是主要形式(57.1%),其次是鼻内瓣膜受累(38.1%)。值得注意的是,NOSE评分与AAR结果没有可靠的相关性,这凸显了主观评估工具的局限性。鼻中隔偏曲(52.5%)和鼻甲肥大(23.8%)等结构异常也很常见。
本研究强调鼻瓣膜塌陷是初次修复后唇腭裂患者持续性鼻阻塞的一个主要但未被充分认识的因素。像AAR和靶向内镜检查这样的客观评估方法应常规纳入二次鼻整形手术规划中。这些发现提倡对唇腭裂患者的二次鼻重建采取个性化方法,将客观功能数据纳入手术规划。这些策略通过根据个体解剖和生理特征调整干预措施,符合个性化医疗原则。