Dhingra R C, Wyndham C, Bauernfeind R, Denes P, Wu D, Swiryn S, Rosen K M
Circulation. 1979 Jul;60(1):33-9. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.60.1.33.
Eighty-six of 452 patients (19%) with chronic bifascicular block were found to have no clinically apparent associated organic heart disease (OHD) and were defined as having primary conduction disease (PCD). Comparison of patients with PCD and OHD revealed a significantly lower incidence of the following clinical variables in the PCD patients (p less than 0.001): exertional angina, dyspnea, congestive heart failure, cardiomegaly, functional class I (all by study design), left bundle branch block and premature ventricular contractions. Both mean AH and HV intervals were significantly shorter in patients with PCD (p less than 0.01). The incidence of HV prolongation was 21% in PCD and 41% in OHD patients (p less than 0.001). All patients were prospectively followed for 21-2998 days with a mean +/- SEM of 1209 +/- 66 days for PCD and 1172 +/- 36 days for OHD. Atrioventricular (AV) block developed in three patients from the PCD group and 26 from the OHD group (NS), with spontaneous block occurring in one (1%) PCD patient and 19 (5%) OHD patients (p less than 0.05). Annual mortality due to sudden death as well as total cardiovascular mortality (including sudden death) for the 5-year follow-up was significantly lower in patients with PCD. Patients with PCD have significantly lower incidence of electrophysiologic abnormalities and subsequent spontaneous AV block as well as cardiovascular and sudden death mortality. The diagnosis of PCD based on clinical criteria probably underestimates the presence of underlying OHD, as suggested by a small but definite risk of cardiovascular mortality.
452例慢性双分支阻滞患者中,86例(19%)未发现有临床明显相关的器质性心脏病(OHD),被定义为患有原发性传导疾病(PCD)。对PCD患者和OHD患者的比较显示,PCD患者以下临床变量的发生率显著较低(p<0.001):劳力性心绞痛、呼吸困难、充血性心力衰竭、心脏扩大、功能分级I级(均按研究设计)、左束支阻滞和室性早搏。PCD患者的平均AH间期和HV间期均显著缩短(p<0.01)。PCD患者中HV延长的发生率为21%,OHD患者中为41%(p<0.001)。所有患者均进行前瞻性随访21 - 2998天,PCD患者的平均±标准误为1209±66天,OHD患者为1172±36天。PCD组有3例患者发生房室(AV)阻滞,OHD组有26例(无显著性差异),其中PCD组1例(1%)患者和OHD组19例(5%)患者发生自发性阻滞(p<0.05)。PCD患者5年随访的猝死年死亡率以及总心血管死亡率(包括猝死)显著较低。PCD患者的电生理异常、随后的自发性AV阻滞以及心血管和猝死死亡率的发生率显著较低。基于临床标准对PCD的诊断可能低估了潜在OHD的存在,心血管死亡率虽小但确定的风险表明了这一点。