Holmes D R, McKeever W F
Cortex. 1979 Mar;15(1):51-62. doi: 10.1016/s0010-9452(79)80006-4.
The present experiment was concerned with an assessment of possible serial, as opposed to general, memory deficit in dyslexia. Previous studies had consistently confounded general and serial memory assessments. Fifteen specifically dyslexic adolescents and 15 normal-reading controls were administered four separate memory tasks. In the general memory for verbal material task they were shown 20 words, each for three seconds, and were then given a deck of 40 word cards and required to pick out the 20 words just seen. In the serial memory version of the verbal task they were again shown 20 words and subsequently required to reproduce the order in which they had been shown. Two comparable (general and serial) procedures were also administered using faces as the to-be-remembered materials. Results showed comparable performances of the dyslexics and controls on both versions of the face memory task and on the general memory version of the words task. On the serial reproduction version of the verbal task, however, dyslexics were found to be significantly impaired relative to controls. Thus, adolescent dyslexics appear to have a memory impairment which is specific for both type of material (verbal) and type of memory (serial). The results are compatible with Orton's (1937) speculation regarding "sequecing" and "memory" in dyslexia and with the view that the defect resides within the neuropsychological processes of the language-dominant hemisphere.
本实验旨在评估诵读困难症患者可能存在的系列记忆缺陷,而非一般记忆缺陷,以往的研究一直将一般记忆评估和系列记忆评估混为一谈。对15名患有特定诵读困难症的青少年和15名正常阅读的对照组进行了四项不同的记忆任务测试。在言语材料的一般记忆任务中,向他们展示20个单词,每个单词展示三秒,然后给他们一副40张单词卡片,要求他们从中挑出刚才看到的20个单词。在言语任务的系列记忆版本中,再次向他们展示20个单词,随后要求他们按展示的顺序进行复述。还使用面孔作为待记忆材料进行了两个类似的(一般和系列)程序。结果显示,诵读困难症患者和对照组在面孔记忆任务的两个版本以及单词任务的一般记忆版本上表现相当。然而,在言语任务的系列复述版本中,发现诵读困难症患者相对于对照组有明显受损。因此,青少年诵读困难症患者似乎存在一种对材料类型(言语)和记忆类型(系列)都特定的记忆障碍。这些结果与奥顿(1937年)关于诵读困难症中“序列”和“记忆”的推测以及缺陷存在于语言优势半球的神经心理过程中的观点相符。