Sheldon B L, Milton M K
Genetics. 1972 Aug;71(4):567-95. doi: 10.1093/genetics/71.4.567.
Results are presented of 135 generations of selection for high scutellar bristle number in two lines M and M3 derived from the same original mating of one female with 5 bristles by one male with 4 bristles, the latter being the wild-type canalised phenotype. Results are also given of two relaxed lines per line and of a reselection line M2 derived from the first relaxed line of line M which had regressed almost to base population level. The effect of introducing the sc(1) allele into the M and M3 selected backgrounds was studied at generations 39-44. At the end of selection the effect of an extra dose of sc(+) was also studied in males of all selected backgrounds. The correlated responses in abdominal bristles were followed in all lines.-Considering their common origin, the selection lines differed markedly in pattern of scutellar response and in most other aspects observed, namely correlated responses in abdominals and p.c. scutellars, sex differences, and behaviour on relaxation. Selection limits for scutellar bristles in lines M and M2 were equal to or greater than the most extreme reported in the literature.-The probit span of the canalised 4 bristle class decreased in each selection line as the mean scutellar bristle number increased, and increased again in the relaxed lines as the mean bristle number decreased. In the context of an hypothesis that canalisation at 4 bristle is due to regulation of the scute locus, this result is now interpreted as being due mainly to selection for poor regulators of sc(+), in contrast to a previous interpretation that only the minor gene background was altered by selection, the canalisation (regulation) genotype not being affected.-Introducing the sc(1) allele into the selected backgrounds M and M3 showed a reduced effect on sc(1) flies compared with sc(+) flies, and an interaction of sc(1) and sc(+) with selected background. sc(1) flies had about the same number of bristles in both backgrounds though the mean of sc(+) flies in line M was about 3sigma higher than in line M3. Dominance of sc(+) to sc(1) was reduced slightly in M3. However, the effect of an extra dose of sc(+) at the end of selection was about the same as in unselected in all lines, so the first or dominance level of regulation of the scute locus was not significantly affected by selection, though the second or canalisation level of regulation was.-A large positive correlated response in abdominal bristles occurred in all lines. The response in line M was about twice that in M2 and M3 and was in fact as large as can be obtained from direct selection on abdominals. In line M some genes may have been selected with a proportionately greater effect on abdominals than on scutellars. This is supported by the further observation in line M that the abdominal scores of flies with particular scutellar bristles scores increased as the scutellar mean increased. An attempt was made to apply to these results Rendel's (1962) model of competition between scutellars and abdominals for common bristle-making resources. This could not be done satisfactorily mainly because the assumptions in the model about the similarity of effects in scute and wild-type flies were not met in the present material.
本文展示了对源自同一原始交配组合(一只具有5根刚毛的雌性与一只具有4根刚毛的雄性交配,后者为野生型定型表型)的M和M3两个品系进行135代高盾片刚毛数选择的结果。还给出了每个品系的两个放松选择品系以及源自M品系第一个放松选择品系且几乎已回归到基础群体水平的重新选择品系M2的结果。在第39 - 44代研究了将sc(1)等位基因引入M和M3选择背景的影响。在选择结束时,还研究了所有选择背景的雄性中额外剂量的sc(+)的影响。跟踪了所有品系腹部刚毛的相关反应。考虑到它们的共同起源,选择品系在盾片反应模式以及观察到的大多数其他方面存在显著差异,即腹部和盾片百分比的相关反应、性别差异以及放松选择时的表现。M和M2品系中盾片刚毛的选择极限等于或大于文献中报道的最极端值。随着盾片刚毛平均数增加,每个选择品系中4根刚毛定型类别的概率跨度减小,而随着刚毛平均数减少,放松选择品系中的概率跨度再次增加。在4根刚毛处的定型是由于对scute位点的调控这一假设背景下,该结果现在被解释为主要是由于对sc(+)不良调控因子的选择,这与之前仅选择改变次要基因背景、定型(调控)基因型不受影响的解释形成对比。将sc(1)等位基因引入选择背景M和M3中,与sc(+)果蝇相比,对sc(1)果蝇的影响较小,且sc(1)和sc(+)与选择背景存在相互作用。sc(1)果蝇在两种背景下的刚毛数大致相同,尽管M品系中sc(+)果蝇的平均数比M3品系高约3倍标准差。在M3中sc(+)对sc(1)的显性略有降低。然而,选择结束时额外剂量的sc(+)的影响在所有品系中与未选择时大致相同,因此scute位点的一级或显性调控水平未受到选择的显著影响,尽管二级或定型调控水平受到了影响。所有品系中腹部刚毛都出现了较大的正向相关反应。M品系中的反应约为M2和M3品系的两倍,实际上与直接对腹部进行选择所能获得的反应一样大。在M品系中,一些基因对腹部的选择作用可能比对盾片的选择作用更大。M品系中进一步的观察结果支持了这一点,即具有特定盾片刚毛分数的果蝇的腹部得分随着盾片平均数的增加而增加。尝试将Rendel(1962)关于盾片和腹部争夺共同刚毛形成资源的竞争模型应用于这些结果。但这无法令人满意地完成,主要是因为该模型中关于scute和野生型果蝇效应相似性的假设在当前材料中未得到满足。