Harker D
Biophys J. 1972 Oct;12(10):1285-95. doi: 10.1016/S0006-3495(72)86162-9.
The present work consists of a new interpretation of the data presented in the article entitled "X-Ray Diffraction of Myelin Membrane. II" by C. K. Akers and D. F. Parsons (1970, Biophys. J.10:116). It will be shown that the projection of the electron density onto the normal to the myelin multilayer derived by these authors is no more consistent with their data than another electron density function, or, perhaps, its negative. (A density function and its negative are related as follows: one of them is a certain density distribution, the other is the same function subtracted from a constant uniform density. Two density functions so related produce identical diffracted intensities.) The Fourier series for the projection of the electron density onto the normal to the myelin multilayer has coefficients +/-hI(h) where I(h) are the intensities of the five orders of reflection; data from which these can be estimated are presented by Akers and Parsons. The sequence of signs found here is + - - + + for the positive density (or - + + - - for the negative one). Quantitative agreement exists between the five X-ray diffraction data of Akers and Parsons and the same intensities calculated from the new model of the myelin structure described here. In this model the myelin double layer, 171 A thick, consists of a central lipid layer 72.4 A thick covered on both surfaces by protein layers 6.9 A thick; these protein layers are covered, in turn, by other lipid layers 42.4 A thick. Minor modifications of this model will no doubt be required to produce agreement between the observed and calculated intensities of the higher order reflections.
本研究对C.K. 埃克斯和D.F. 帕森斯(1970年,《生物物理杂志》10:116)发表的题为《髓鞘膜的X射线衍射。II》一文中的数据进行了新的解读。结果表明,相较于另一种电子密度函数,或者其负值,这些作者推导的电子密度在垂直于髓鞘多层结构方向上的投影与他们的数据并不更加一致。(一个密度函数与其负值的关系如下:其中一个是特定的密度分布,另一个是从恒定均匀密度中减去相同函数得到的。如此相关的两个密度函数会产生相同的衍射强度。)电子密度在垂直于髓鞘多层结构方向上投影的傅里叶级数系数为+/-[hI(h)]^(1/2),其中I(h)是五个反射级次的强度;埃克斯和帕森斯给出了可据此估算这些系数的数据。这里发现的正密度的符号序列是 + - - + +(负密度的符号序列是 - + + - -)。埃克斯和帕森斯的五个X射线衍射数据与此处描述的髓鞘结构新模型计算出的相同强度之间存在定量一致性。在这个模型中,171埃厚的髓鞘双层由一个72.4埃厚的中央脂质层组成,其两面覆盖着6.9埃厚的蛋白质层;这些蛋白质层又被42.4埃厚的其他脂质层覆盖。无疑需要对这个模型进行一些小的修改,以使高阶反射的观测强度和计算强度达成一致。