Korompal F L, Hayward R H
South Med J. 1979 Sep;72(9):1121-2. doi: 10.1097/00007611-197909000-00010.
To evaluate the contribution of sputum cytology to the diagnosis and treatment of lung cancer, 918 cases of lung cancer were reviewed. Of 105 patients with positive sputum cytology, 93 had other invasive procedures to establish the cell type or stage or to attempt to cure the disease. In 12 patients the presence of positive sputum prevented further invasive evaluation. Thus, the real benefit of sputum cytology was reduced to 12 patients, or little over 1% of the total number of lung cancer patients. It is concluded that sputum cytology is not an effective diagnostic approach to suspected lung cancer. It rarely precluded invasive proceudres because it failed to contribute to the staging of the disease. Therefore, it should be used in only those patients in whom the yield of positive sputum would direct therapy other than surgery.
为评估痰细胞学检查对肺癌诊断和治疗的贡献,对918例肺癌病例进行了回顾性研究。在105例痰细胞学检查呈阳性的患者中,93例接受了其他侵入性检查以确定细胞类型或分期,或试图治愈疾病。在12例患者中,痰检阳性避免了进一步的侵入性评估。因此,痰细胞学检查的实际受益患者仅为12例,占肺癌患者总数的略多于1%。得出结论:痰细胞学检查并非疑似肺癌的有效诊断方法。它很少能避免侵入性检查,因为它对疾病分期没有帮助。因此,仅应将其用于那些痰检阳性结果可指导非手术治疗的患者。