Washington J S, Dick J A, Jacobsen M, Prentice W M
Br J Ind Med. 1973 Oct;30(4):365-74. doi: 10.1136/oem.30.4.365.
365-374. The effect on the quality of chest radiographs using a reciprocating grid with a moderately high kilovoltage (96 to 105 kV) has been studied. A total of 1 710 mineworkers had two postero-anterior chest radiographs taken at the same visit to a linked pair of mobile ϰ-ray units. One film was taken with conventional exposure factors and the other with moderately high kilovoltage and a reciprocating grid. The grid was exchanged between the two units according to a randomized plan so that the first radiograph was not always taken with the same technique. The 3 420 films so produced were subsequently assessed for quality by five doctors experienced in reading chest films. The films were examined singly in random order and the reader did not know which technique had been used for a given film. Four of the readers recorded improved quality using the grid technique for films from men whose antero-posterior chest measurements exceeded 254 mm (10 in), but they preferred the conventional exposure technique for films from men whose chest measurements were less than 254 mm. Results from all film pairs where a difference in quality was recorded showed no overall advantage for either technique.
365 - 374. 研究了使用中等高千伏(96至105千伏)的往复式滤线栅对胸部X光片质量的影响。共有1710名矿工在同一次就诊时,由一对相连的移动X光设备拍摄了两张后前位胸部X光片。一张胶片采用传统曝光参数拍摄,另一张采用中等高千伏和往复式滤线栅拍摄。滤线栅根据随机方案在两台设备之间交换,这样第一张X光片并不总是采用相同的技术拍摄。随后,由五名有阅读胸部X光片经验的医生对这样产生的3420张胶片进行质量评估。胶片按随机顺序单独检查,阅片者不知道给定的胶片使用了哪种技术。四名阅片者记录到,对于前后胸径超过254毫米(10英寸)的男性的胶片,使用滤线栅技术质量有所提高,但对于胸径小于254毫米的男性的胶片,他们更喜欢传统曝光技术。在记录到质量有差异的所有胶片对中,两种技术总体上都没有优势。