Gradillas E L, Volz R G
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1979 May(140):153-8.
The postoperative results and complications among 41 patients undergoing bilateral total knee arthroplasty were compared with 40 patients who underwent unilateral total knee replacement. Among the bilateral group, the most common diagnosis was rheumatoid arthritis (68%), while degenerative arthritis prevailed in the unilateral group (50%). Preoperatively, patients in the bilateral group exhibited generally a greater degree of physical disability and limitation of activity due to multiple joint involvement. Postoperatively, no change in the arc of motion was noted in either group, although flexion contractures were significantly diminished in both. The degree of postoperative pain relief was identical in both groups as was the decreased need for walking devices. The most commonly observed complication among the unilateral group was prosthetic loosening (12.%). This was felt explainable on the basis of the increased postoperative activity level of patients with degenerative arthritis and single joint disease. Patients in the bilateral group showed a higher incidence of wound problems, presumably secondary to the long-term use of steroids. The infection rate was identical in each group, but the bilateral group displayed a higher incidence of pulmonary emboli (9.7 vs. 2.5%). The postoperative need for rehabilitation services and the duration of time before dependent walking was achieved was not prolonged in the bilateral group. Hospitalization of the bilateral group was increased only 20%. No deaths were reported in either group. When the need for total knee replacement exists bilaterally, bilateral replacement with a single anesthetic would appear reasonable, provided careful patient selection and technical guidelines are followed.
对41例行双侧全膝关节置换术的患者与40例行单侧全膝关节置换术的患者的术后结果及并发症进行了比较。在双侧置换组中,最常见的诊断是类风湿关节炎(68%),而单侧置换组中退行性关节炎最为常见(50%)。术前,双侧置换组患者由于多关节受累,通常表现出更大程度的身体残疾和活动受限。术后,两组患者的活动弧度均无变化,尽管两组的屈曲挛缩均明显减轻。两组术后疼痛缓解程度相同,对助行器的需求减少程度也相同。单侧置换组最常见的并发症是假体松动(12%)。这被认为是由于退行性关节炎和单关节疾病患者术后活动水平增加所致。双侧置换组患者伤口问题的发生率较高,推测是长期使用类固醇的继发结果。每组的感染率相同,但双侧置换组肺栓塞的发生率较高(9.7%对2.5%)。双侧置换组术后对康复服务的需求以及实现独立行走前的时间并未延长。双侧置换组的住院时间仅增加了20%。两组均未报告死亡病例。当双侧都需要进行全膝关节置换时,在遵循仔细的患者选择和技术指南的情况下,单次麻醉下行双侧置换似乎是合理的。