Murphy H B
Can J Psychiatry. 1979 Aug;24(5):437-49. doi: 10.1177/070674377902400511.
When guilt feelings and self-accusations made their first appearance as symptoms of depression in Europe and Africa, as noted in a previous paper, this followed a period of heightened witchcraft beliefs in both locations and was sometimes first noticed in the form of voluntary witchcraft confessions, raising the question of a possible connection between the two types of change. Using the concepts of "group ego" and "group super-ego" to which Eric Wittkower has contributed, it is suggested that the heightened witchcraft beliefs were a defence against an individualizing change which would eventually lead to the inward turning to aggression and reproach and hence to the symptoms mentioned.
正如在前一篇论文中所指出的,当内疚感和自我指责作为抑郁症症状首次在欧洲和非洲出现时,这之前在这两个地区都经历了一段巫术信仰增强的时期,而且有时是以自愿承认巫术的形式首次被注意到的,这就引发了这两种变化之间可能存在联系的问题。运用埃里克·维特考尔所提出的“群体自我”和“群体超我”的概念,有人认为,巫术信仰的增强是对一种个体化变化的防御,这种变化最终会导致向内转向攻击和自责,进而引发上述症状。