Muggleton P W, Prince G H, Hilton M L
Lancet. 1975 Jun 21;1(7921):1353-5. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(75)92261-8.
Intravenous injection of heat-killed or irradiated B.C.G into tuberculin-positive guineapigs produced macroscopic lesions in the lung when examined 10 days or 4 or 6 weeks later. Microscopically, granulomas typical of a delayed hypersensitivity reaction were seen. Intravenous B.C.G. in normal guineapigs did not produce lesions. At equivalent doses to the killed vaccine, viable vaccine caused only mild lesions. Liver lesions were also found on early examination but by 4 weeks had almost resolved. Acid/alcohol-fast bacteria were only rarely detected. Purified portein derivative did not produce lesions, and antihistamine treatment did not modify the results. These results suggest that B.C.G. should be given by the intravenous route for cancer immunotherapy in man with great caution, especially in tuberculin-sensitive persons. The guineapig observations stress that hypersensitisation is a potential complicating feature of cancer immunotherapy, and this is discussed in the light of published clinical experience of B.C.G. by various routes. It is concluded that B.C.G. vaccines with a high proportion of viable organisms are to be preferred.
给结核菌素呈阳性的豚鼠静脉注射热灭活或经辐射的卡介苗,在10天后或4周或6周后检查时,肺部会出现肉眼可见的病变。在显微镜下,可以看到典型的迟发型超敏反应肉芽肿。给正常豚鼠静脉注射卡介苗不会产生病变。与灭活疫苗剂量相当的活疫苗只会引起轻微病变。早期检查时也发现了肝脏病变,但到4周时几乎已消退。很少检测到抗酸菌。纯化蛋白衍生物不会产生病变,抗组胺治疗也不会改变结果。这些结果表明,在人类癌症免疫治疗中,通过静脉途径给予卡介苗时应极其谨慎,尤其是对结核菌素敏感的人。豚鼠实验结果强调,超敏反应是癌症免疫治疗中一个潜在的复杂因素,本文结合已发表的关于不同途径卡介苗临床经验对此进行了讨论。得出的结论是,应优先选择活生物体比例高的卡介苗。