Smith P B, Rhoden D L, Tomfohrde K M, Dunn C R, Balows A, Hermann G J
Appl Microbiol. 1971 Jun;21(6):1036-9. doi: 10.1128/am.21.6.1036-1039.1971.
The R/B Enteric Differential System for identifying enteric bacteria has been evaluated with 451 "unknown" cultures from the stock culture collection of the Center for Disease Control. An average of 89.6% of these cultures were correctly identified by the R/B system, when used as recommended by the manufacturer but without the assistance of serology. This percentage ranged, however, from 47% for Klebsiella to 100% for Serratia and Providencia. Of 11 groups or genera of Enterobacteriaceae tested, only three (Enterobacter, Serratia, and Providencia) were identified with 95% or better accuracy. Four groups (Arizona, Citrobacter, Escherichia, and Salmonella) attained 90 to 95% accuracy of identification, and three groups (Edwardsiella, Proteus, and Shigella) scored between 85 and 90% accuracy. We recommend the R/B system as a screening device which is reasonably successful in grouping bacteria but not as a substitute for more exacting conventional procedures.
用于鉴定肠道细菌的R/B肠道鉴别系统已通过疾病控制中心菌种保藏中心的451份“未知”培养物进行了评估。按照制造商的建议使用该R/B系统,但不借助血清学方法时,平均有89.6%的这些培养物得到了正确鉴定。然而,这一百分比范围从克雷伯菌属的47%到沙雷菌属和普罗威登斯菌属的100%。在所测试的11个肠杆菌科菌群或属中,只有三个(肠杆菌属、沙雷菌属和普罗威登斯菌属)的鉴定准确率达到95%或更高。四个菌群(亚利桑那菌属、柠檬酸杆菌属、大肠杆菌属和沙门菌属)的鉴定准确率达到90%至95%,三个菌群(爱德华菌属、变形杆菌属和志贺菌属)的准确率在85%至90%之间。我们推荐将R/B系统作为一种筛选工具,它在细菌分组方面相当成功,但不能替代更严格的传统方法。