Sauguet J, Benton A L, Hécaen H
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1971 Oct;34(5):496-501. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.34.5.496.
The relationship of disturbances of the body schema to hemispheric locus of lesion and sensory aphasic disorder was assessed by giving verbal and non-verbal tests of right-left orientation, finger recognition, and autotopagnosis to patients with unilateral cerebral disease. The study was restricted to right-handed patients who were free from general mental impairment or confusion. The tests were also given to a group of control patients whose performances defined the range of normal performance in each test. A significant proportion of patients with sensory aphasic disorder performed defectively on all the tests, non-verbal as well as verbal, the relative frequency of failure in this group ranging from 10 to 67% for the different tests. There were, however, a number of patients with sensory aphasic disorder who performed adequately on most of the tests. Defective performance on the part of non-aphasic patients with lesions of either the left or the right hemisphere was quite rare in the case of 19 of the 20 tests. The exceptional test was the task of imitating lateral movements from Head's battery, on which both non-aphasic groups performed relatively poorly. The patients with lesions of the right hemisphere were significantly inferior to those with left hemisphere disease on this test. The findings are interpreted as indicating that sensory aphasic disorder is a necessary but not sufficient condition for the occurrence of some types of bilateral body schema' disturbance in patients with unilateral disease. It is postulated that the sufficient condition is a combination of aphasic disorder with somatosensory impairment. Bilateral impairment of the body schema' does not appear to have a differential relationship to hemispheric locus of lesion per se.
通过对单侧脑部疾病患者进行左右定向、手指识别和自体部位觉的言语及非言语测试,评估身体图式障碍与病变半球位置及感觉性失语症之间的关系。该研究仅限于无一般精神障碍或意识模糊的右利手患者。对一组对照患者也进行了测试,他们的表现确定了每项测试的正常表现范围。相当一部分感觉性失语症患者在所有测试(包括非言语和言语测试)中表现不佳,该组不同测试中的失败相对频率在10%至67%之间。然而,有一些感觉性失语症患者在大多数测试中表现良好。在20项测试中的19项中,左半球或右半球病变的非失语症患者表现不佳的情况相当罕见。例外的测试是Head测试组中的模仿侧向运动任务,两个非失语症组在该任务上表现相对较差。在这项测试中,右半球病变的患者明显不如左半球疾病患者。研究结果被解释为表明,感觉性失语症是单侧疾病患者出现某些类型双侧“身体图式”障碍的必要但非充分条件。据推测,充分条件是失语症与躯体感觉障碍的结合。“身体图式”的双侧损害本身似乎与病变半球位置没有差异关系。