Greer S, Bagley C
Br Med J. 1971 Feb 6;1(5744):310-2. doi: 10.1136/bmj.1.5744.310.
All patients presenting at the casualty department of King's College Hospital during the first six months of 1968 with deliberate self-poisoning or self-injury were followed up. Of 211 patients 204 (97%) were traced after a mean interval of 18 months (range one to two years). Despite official hospital policy, 22% had not been seen by a psychiatrist before discharge; these 44 untreated patients were compared with the remaining 160 who had received either brief (one or two interviews) or more prolonged psychiatric and social help.Subsequent suicidal attempts occurred significantly more often among untreated than among treated patients, prolonged treatment being associated with the best prognosis. The same trend was observed in respect of actual suicide, though the numbers were small and differences did not reach statistical significance. These findings held good when the untreated and treated groups were controlled for other variables which were found to be correlated with outcome. These results indicate that psychiatric intervention is associated with a significant reduction in subsequent suicidal behaviour.
对1968年头6个月在国王学院医院急诊科因蓄意自我中毒或自我伤害就诊的所有患者进行了随访。在211名患者中,平均间隔18个月(1至2年)后追踪到了204名(97%)。尽管有医院的官方政策,但22%的患者在出院前未接受精神科医生诊治;将这44名未接受治疗的患者与其余160名接受过简短(一或两次访谈)或更长期精神科和社会帮助的患者进行了比较。未接受治疗的患者随后自杀未遂的情况明显比接受治疗的患者更频繁,长期治疗的预后最佳。在实际自杀方面也观察到了同样的趋势,尽管人数较少且差异未达到统计学显著性。当对未治疗组和治疗组的其他与结果相关的变量进行控制时,这些发现依然成立。这些结果表明,精神科干预与随后自杀行为的显著减少相关。