Lindsay J, Ounsted C, Richards P
Dev Med Child Neurol. 1979 Oct;21(5):630-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8749.1979.tb01677.x.
One hundred children with temporal lobe epilepsy were followed into adult life. 85 per cent had had psychiatric problems in childhood. The occurrence of overt psychiatric disorder in adult life was low: of those survivors who were not gravely mentally retarded, 70 per cent were regarded as psychiatrically healthy. Overt schizophreniform psychosis has developed in 10 per cent of survivors. Males with continuing epilepsy and left-sided foci were at special risk: 30 per cent of such patients had become psychotic. No patient coded as having a right-sided focus in 1964 had become psychotic by 1977. Though 26 patients had had grossly disordered childhood homes, this factor had no significant relation to adult psychiatric disorder. Antisocial conduct marked the adult life of 12 patients. Their childhood codes showed that male sex, a focus contralateral to the preferred hand, and unremittent epilepsy marked this group. Low intelligence and childhood rages were also prominent. Treated neurotic and depressive illness was quite uncommon. Only five survivors have fallen into this category. Those patients escaping psychiatric ill-health are often notably extraverted and successful.
一百名患有颞叶癫痫的儿童被随访至成年期。85%的儿童曾有过精神问题。成年期明显精神障碍的发生率较低:在那些没有严重智力迟钝的幸存者中,70%被视为精神健康。10%的幸存者出现了明显的精神分裂症样精神病。患有持续性癫痫且病灶在左侧的男性有特殊风险:这类患者中有30%已出现精神病症状。1964年被编码为右侧病灶的患者到1977年都没有出现精神病症状。虽然有26名患者童年家庭环境严重紊乱,但这一因素与成年期精神障碍并无显著关联。12名患者的成年生活表现出反社会行为。他们童年时期的编码显示,男性、病灶位于优势手对侧以及持续性癫痫是这个群体的特征。低智商和童年时期的暴怒也很突出。经过治疗的神经症和抑郁症相当少见。只有五名幸存者属于这一类。那些没有精神疾病的患者往往格外外向且成功。