Oswald N C, Hinson K F, Canti G, Miller A B
Thorax. 1971 Nov;26(6):623-7. doi: 10.1136/thx.26.6.623.
Of 2,545 in-patients with primary lung cancer, pathological proof of the diagnosis was obtained by sputum cytology in 48%, by bronchoscopy in 32%, by biopsy from miscellaneous sites in 12%, and at thoracotomy or necropsy only in 19%. The diagnosis was made solely on clinical and radiological evidence in 8%. One or more satisfactory specimens of sputum from 2,035 patients gave a positivity rate of 59%. When three specimens of sputum were tested the positivity rate was 69% and when four or more were tested, 85%. The maximum false positivity rate was 0·7%. Agreement between the types of malignant cells found in the sputum and in resected or necropsy specimens occurred in 84%. The pathological diagnosis was based solely on sputum cytology in 40% of the patients in whom malignant cells were found in the sputum. The total work of the sputum laboratories was analysed for one year (1967); sputum was examined from 1,598 patients, of whom 266 (17%) had positive results. Of 1,518 patients who had a bronchoscopy, the positivity rate was 53%, and of 524 patients with biopsies from miscellaneous sites the rate was 64%. Sputum cytology, as practised at present, is a very valuable method of diagnosis, but its demands on time and expertise make it unsuitable for general application outside large medical centres.
在2545例原发性肺癌住院患者中,48%通过痰细胞学检查获得诊断的病理证据,32%通过支气管镜检查,12%通过其他部位活检,仅19%通过开胸手术或尸检获得。8%仅根据临床和影像学证据做出诊断。2035例患者的一份或多份满意痰标本阳性率为59%。检测三份痰标本时阳性率为69%,检测四份或更多份时阳性率为85%。最大假阳性率为0.7%。痰中发现的恶性细胞类型与切除标本或尸检标本中的恶性细胞类型的符合率为84%。在痰中发现恶性细胞的患者中,40%的病理诊断仅基于痰细胞学检查。对痰实验室一年(1967年)的全部工作进行了分析;检查了1598例患者的痰,其中266例(17%)结果为阳性。在1518例接受支气管镜检查的患者中,阳性率为53%,在524例接受其他部位活检的患者中,阳性率为64%。目前实施的痰细胞学检查是一种非常有价值的诊断方法,但它对时间和专业知识的要求使其不适用于大型医疗中心以外的一般应用。