Gros C, Privat J M, Pelissier J, Georgesco M, Benezech J, Ohanna F, Frerebeau P, Simon L, Cadilhac J
Neurochirurgie. 1979;25(3):147-53.
The particular value of clinical, radiological and electromyographical features is compared in 42 patients with motor deficit related to cervicarthrosic myelopathy or amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. The initial onset of the disease was identical (motor deficit and long tracts pathways involvement). Three different groups were identifyed according to the evolution: -- Group I: (13 cases): true lateral amyotrophic sclerosis which were not operated on. -- Group II (10 cases): myelopathy called "cervicarthrosic" because of radiological findings which were operated on but had the same steady worsened course as a lateral amyotrophic sclerosis. -- Group III (19 cases): cervical myelopathy which had surgery. The operation brought about stabilization or fairly good recovery over the 18 months following at least. From a clinical aspect, the "Lhermitte sign" or objective sensitive deficit are strongly significant for cervical myelopathy. On the contrary, diffuse fasciculations specially in the tongue seem to be mostly found in lateral amyotrophic sclerosis, whereas they are restricted into the paralysed area in cervical myelopathy. Electromyographic examination is decisive: simple activity with high frequency motor units (increased amplitude and polyphasic waves) or "preponderant potentials" into a cranial nerve territory or three segments of the lower limbs are frequently found in lateral amyotrophic sclerosis. These electromyographic features are less significant in the upper limbs. The neuroradiological findings lonely cannot assert definitely the cervicarthrosic origin of the myelopathy but visualize the conflicting situation between the spinal cord and the cervical canal and allow to choose the surgical procedure.
对42例与颈椎关节病性脊髓病或肌萎缩侧索硬化相关的运动功能障碍患者的临床、放射学和肌电图特征的特殊价值进行了比较。疾病的初始发作相同(运动功能障碍和长束通路受累)。根据病情发展确定了三个不同的组:——第一组:(13例):未经手术治疗的真性侧索肌萎缩硬化症。——第二组(10例):因放射学表现而被称为“颈椎关节病性”的脊髓病,接受了手术,但病情进展与侧索肌萎缩硬化症一样持续恶化。——第三组(19例):接受手术治疗的颈椎病。手术后至少在18个月内病情稳定或恢复良好。从临床角度来看,“莱尔米特征”或客观感觉障碍对颈椎病具有重要意义。相反,弥漫性肌束震颤,尤其是舌部的肌束震颤,似乎多见于侧索肌萎缩硬化症,而在颈椎病中则局限于麻痹区域。肌电图检查具有决定性意义:在侧索肌萎缩硬化症中经常发现高频运动单位的单纯活动(波幅增加和多相波)或脑神经支配区域或下肢三个节段的“优势电位”。这些肌电图特征在上肢的意义较小。神经放射学检查结果单独不能明确肯定脊髓病的颈椎关节病起源,但可显示脊髓与颈椎管之间的矛盾情况,并有助于选择手术方式。