Anderson J, Dowling M A, Day J L, Pettingale K W
Postgrad Med J. 1970 Oct;46(540):606-12. doi: 10.1136/pgmj.46.540.606.
Videotape recording apparatus was used to make records of case histories obtained from patients by students and doctors. These records were studied in order to identify the skills required to obtain a patient's history of illness. Each skill was defined. A questionnaire was developed in order to assess these skills and three independent observers watched the records of eighteen students and completed a questionnaire for each. The results of this were analysed for reliability and reproducibility between examiners. Moderate reliability and reproducibility were demonstrated. The questionnaire appeared to be a valid method of assessment and was capable of providing significant discrimination between students for each skill. A components analysis suggested that the marks for each skill depend on an overall impression obtained by each examiner and this overall impression is influenced by different skills for each examiner.
使用录像设备记录学生和医生从患者那里获取的病历。对这些记录进行研究,以确定获取患者病史所需的技能。对每项技能进行了定义。设计了一份问卷来评估这些技能,三名独立观察员观看了18名学生的记录,并为每人填写了一份问卷。对结果进行了分析,以检验考官之间的信度和再现性。结果显示出中等的信度和再现性。该问卷似乎是一种有效的评估方法,能够对学生的每项技能进行显著区分。成分分析表明,每项技能的分数取决于每位考官获得的总体印象,而这种总体印象又受到每位考官不同技能的影响。