Samuels L
Schizophr Bull. 1979;5(1):8-10. doi: 10.1093/schbul/5.1.8.
In response to my discussion of sex differences in concordance rates for schizophrenia in twins, Lewine (1979) noted that male schizophrenics are hospitalized earlier than females. He questioned whether females had been followed through the risk period. To clarify, I calculated the age at followup of discordant twins in three studies. In Gottesman and Shields' (1972) study, the majority of both male and female co-twins were still under the age of 45. In contrast, all but a few of Kringlen's (1967a, 1967b, 1968) and Fischer's (1973) co-twins were 45 or over. Their findings support the conclusion that recent twin studies show no significant sex differences in concordance.
针对我对双胞胎精神分裂症一致率性别差异的讨论,莱文(1979年)指出,男性精神分裂症患者比女性更早住院。他质疑女性是否在整个风险期都得到了跟踪研究。为了弄清楚,我在三项研究中计算了不一致双胞胎的随访年龄。在戈特曼和希尔兹(1972年)的研究中,大多数同性别的双胞胎仍未满45岁。相比之下,克林根(1967年a、1967年b、1968年)和菲舍尔(1973年)的双胞胎中,除了少数几个外,其他的都在45岁及以上。他们的研究结果支持了近期双胞胎研究显示一致率不存在显著性别差异这一结论。