Knudson K H, Kagan S
J Genet Psychol. 1977 Dec;131(2d Half):243-53. doi: 10.1080/00221325.1977.10533296.
Ability to take the perspective of another was studied among 97 5 to 6- and 7 to 9-year-old Anglo American and Mexican American boys and girls. These children were administered seven perceptual role-taking tasks and the Children's Embedded Figures Test of field-independence. Results indicated no significant cultural differences. Results were contrary to previous findings in three aspects: (a) children were able to take the role of another younger than originally theorized by Piaget; (b) role-taking and field-independence were not significantly related when age is controlled; and (c) low and inconsistent correlations among the visual perspective role-taking tasks indicate that visual perspective role-taking is not an established unidimensional construct.
对97名5至6岁以及7至9岁的英裔美国和墨西哥裔美国男孩和女孩进行了换位思考能力的研究。这些孩子接受了七项感知换位思考任务以及儿童镶嵌图形测验以评估场独立性。结果表明不存在显著的文化差异。结果在三个方面与之前的研究结果相反:(a) 儿童能够换位思考的对象比皮亚杰最初理论所认为的年龄更小;(b) 在控制年龄的情况下,换位思考与场独立性没有显著关联;(c) 视觉换位思考任务之间的低且不一致的相关性表明视觉换位思考不是一个既定的单维结构。