Rutter M
Am J Psychiatry. 1982 Jan;139(1):21-33. doi: 10.1176/ajp.139.1.21.
The author considers two main concepts of minimal brain dysfunction: 1) a continuum notion, in which minimal brain dysfunction is viewed as a lesser variant of gross traumatic brain damage, and 2) a syndrome notion, in which minimal brain dysfunction constitutes a genetically determined disorder rather than a response to any form of injury. The evidence on the former indicates that subclinical damage to the brain may occur and may involve psychological sequelae-but the damage probably has to be rather severe, and the result is not a homogeneous syndrome. The second alternative remains a possibility, but the claims far outrun the empirical findings that could justify them.
1)连续统一体概念,即轻微脑功能障碍被视为严重创伤性脑损伤的较轻变体;2)综合征概念,即轻微脑功能障碍构成一种由基因决定的疾病,而非对任何形式损伤的反应。关于前者的证据表明,大脑可能发生亚临床损伤,且可能涉及心理后遗症——但这种损伤可能必须相当严重,而且结果并非一种同质的综合征。第二种可能性仍然存在,但相关主张远远超出了能够证明其合理性的实证研究结果。