Kitaoka K, Ito T, Tashiro K, Abe H, Tsuru M, Miyasaka K
No Shinkei Geka. 1982 May;10(5):501-9.
Twelve cases of cerebellar astrocytoma experienced in the Department of Neurosurgery, Hokkaido University School of Medicine were examined primarily for tumor stain and pathological tumor circulation by angiography. In addition, comparison on neuroradiological findings between cerebellar astrocytoma and hemispheric supratentorial astrocytoma (low-grade) was carried out, and neuroradiological differential diagnosis of cerebellar astrocytoma and cerebellar hemangioblastoma was discussed on the basis of the present results and those which were already reported by other investigations and the authors. The results are as follows: 1) Tumor stain was observed in only one case. A tumor was demonstrated as an avascular mass in the remaining 12 cases. 2) Demonstration of cerebellar astrocytoma as hypovascular or avascular masses was related to their low-grade malignancy in histology and cystic nature in gross appearance, as already pointed out. Furthermore, the present study suggested that mural nodules of cystic lesions should have certain weight and sizes so that they could be demonstrated as tumor stain. 3) Abnormal findings concerning tumor circulation were mostly limited to the cases with tumor stain. Early filling veins were not found in any case. Neither feeding artery nor draining vein was clearly identified in some cases. In addition, the abnormal vessels lacked hypertrophic and tortuous changes. 4) In the supratentorial region, five of the 12 low-grade astrocytoma exhibited abnormal tumor stain and tumor circulation by cerebral angiogram and we think that supratentorial and posterior fossa astrocytoma must usually exhibit different pathological tumor circulation by cerebral angiogram, since each group has distinctive clinical and biological characteristics. 5) CT was performed in 7 of 13 cases. It appeared to be more useful than cerebral angiography in the morphological diagnosis Especially in cystic tumors, CT produced minute information concerning peritumoral edema, enhancement of margin of cystic astrocytoma after intravenous contrast medium, and marginal enhancement with layering in the dependent part of the cyst. 6) Neuroradiological different diagnosis of cerebellar astrocytoma and cerebellar hemangioblastoma by CT was difficult in our cases of cystic tumors. However, both tumors were differentiated from each other with ease by tumor stain and tumor circulation in cerebral angiography, since cerebellar astrocytoma was lacking in abnormal vessels, whereas cerebellar hemangioblastoma was marked by many abnormal vessels. Thus, we concluded that cerebral angiography is superior to CT in differential diagnosis between cerebellar astrocytoma and cerebellar hemangioblastoma.
北海道大学医学院神经外科收治的12例小脑星形细胞瘤患者,主要通过血管造影检查肿瘤染色及肿瘤病理循环情况。此外,对小脑星形细胞瘤与幕上半球星形细胞瘤(低级别)的神经放射学表现进行了比较,并根据本研究结果以及其他研究和作者已报道的结果,对小脑星形细胞瘤与小脑成血管细胞瘤的神经放射学鉴别诊断进行了讨论。结果如下:1)仅1例观察到肿瘤染色。其余12例肿瘤表现为无血管肿块。2)如前所述,小脑星形细胞瘤表现为低血供或无血管肿块与它们组织学上的低恶性程度及大体外观上的囊性性质有关。此外,本研究表明囊性病变的壁结节应有一定的大小和重量,以便能显示为肿瘤染色。3)关于肿瘤循环的异常表现大多局限于有肿瘤染色的病例。任何病例均未发现早期充盈静脉。部分病例既未明确识别出供血动脉,也未明确识别出引流静脉。此外,异常血管缺乏增粗和迂曲改变。4)在幕上区域,12例低级别星形细胞瘤中有5例通过脑血管造影显示出异常的肿瘤染色和肿瘤循环,并且我们认为幕上和后颅窝星形细胞瘤通常通过脑血管造影会表现出不同的肿瘤病理循环,因为每组具有独特的临床和生物学特征。5)13例患者中有7例进行了CT检查。在形态学诊断方面,CT似乎比脑血管造影更有用。特别是在囊性肿瘤中,CT提供了有关肿瘤周围水肿、静脉注射造影剂后囊性星形细胞瘤边缘强化以及囊肿下垂部位边缘分层强化的详细信息。6)在我们的囊性肿瘤病例中,通过CT对小脑星形细胞瘤和小脑成血管细胞瘤进行神经放射学鉴别诊断很困难。然而,通过脑血管造影的肿瘤染色和肿瘤循环,这两种肿瘤很容易相互区分,因为小脑星形细胞瘤缺乏异常血管,而小脑成血管细胞瘤则有许多异常血管。因此,我们得出结论,在小脑星形细胞瘤与小脑成血管细胞瘤的鉴别诊断中,脑血管造影优于CT。