Grossman Z
Immunol Rev. 1984 Jun;79:119-38. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-065x.1984.tb00490.x.
It is suggested that immunologic specificity and selective responsiveness, assayed by effector and memory cells, are, in part, determined by the existing repertoire of lymphocytes and, in part, by the dynamic nature of cellular growth. Clones within horizontal networks resemble competing species in a Darwinian world. Upon stimulation, the development of a clone is greatly affected, in a dynamic way, by factors that determine the balance between self-renewal and differentiation. Antigen is a major factor. The amount of antigen and the nature of encounter with the immune system (sudden, graded or continuous), through the selection of a particular subset of clones, can be correlated with a weak or a strong expression of effector function and with the generation of effective memory or of tolerance. The encounter with self antigens obeys the same rules. Thus, the distinction between self and non-self is a quantitative one, both at the single-cell level and at the systemic level. The encounter of developing lymphocytes with self antigens, and in particular with idiotypes and MHC-antigens, restricts the repertoire and imposes major constraints both on the mode of interaction with foreign antigens and on potential self-recognition networks. The proposed "dynamic scheme", differing from "structural schemes" in a number of fundamental aspects, calls for reevaluation of present concepts of immunoregulation and for reinterpretation of data.
有人提出,通过效应细胞和记忆细胞检测的免疫特异性和选择性反应性,部分取决于淋巴细胞的现有库,部分取决于细胞生长的动态性质。水平网络中的克隆类似于达尔文世界中的竞争物种。受到刺激后,克隆的发育会以动态方式受到决定自我更新与分化之间平衡的因素的极大影响。抗原是主要因素。抗原的量以及与免疫系统接触的性质(突然、分级或持续),通过选择特定的克隆亚群,可以与效应功能的弱或强表达以及有效记忆或耐受性的产生相关联。与自身抗原的接触遵循相同的规则。因此,自我与非自我之间的区别在单细胞水平和系统水平上都是定量的。发育中的淋巴细胞与自身抗原,特别是与独特型和MHC抗原的接触,会限制库,并对外来抗原的相互作用模式和潜在的自我识别网络施加重大限制。提出的“动态方案”在许多基本方面与“结构方案”不同,需要重新评估当前的免疫调节概念并重新解释数据。