Cuddy P G, Elenbaas J K, Coit K J
J Biocommun. 1984 Aug;11(3):2-4.
The effectiveness of a slide-tape program on literature evaluation skills was assessed. The slide-tape program was viewed by nine medical students (group 1) on an individual basis. Nine additional medical students (group 2) attended a lecture which addressed the same topic. Computerized questionnaire responses were obtained before and after viewing the program and the conventional lecture. No significant differences were observed between groups 1 and 2 in pre- and post-test responses (p greater than 0.05); however, significant improvement in score was observed in both groups after viewing the program and the lecture (p less than 0.05). The slide-tape program was felt to be comparable to the conventional lecture in introducing the concepts of literature evaluation.
评估了一个幻灯片录像程序对文献评估技能的有效性。九名医科学生(第1组)各自观看了该幻灯片录像程序。另外九名医科学生(第2组)参加了一个关于同一主题的讲座。在观看该程序和传统讲座之前及之后,获取了计算机化问卷调查的回复。第1组和第2组在测试前和测试后的回复中未观察到显著差异(p大于0.05);然而,在观看该程序和讲座后,两组的分数均有显著提高(p小于0.05)。人们认为,在介绍文献评估概念方面,幻灯片录像程序与传统讲座相当。