Kelsey S F, Mullin S M, Detre K M, Mitchell H, Cowley M J, Gruentzig A R, Kent K M
Am J Cardiol. 1984 Jun 15;53(12):56C-64C. doi: 10.1016/0002-9149(84)90747-1.
The NHLBI PTCA Registry collected clinical data on 3,101 PTCA procedures performed at 105 clinical centers between September 1977 and September 1981. To investigate the "learning curve" from introduction through the early application of this new therapy for revascularization, success rates and complication rates were examined by calendar year and according to investigator experience. Success rates improved by calendar year, from 54% in 1979 to 66% in 1981. Investigators with fewer than 50 cases had a success rate of 55%. After an investigator had performed 150 procedures, the success rate was 77%. The increase in success rate was largely the result of a dramatic increase in the ability to cross the narrowing with the catheter, and was accounted for by experience and improved equipment. Patient selection for PTCA was characterized by sex, age, previous CABG, number of diseased coronary arteries and stable Canadian Heart classification over time. Reflecting the increase in the success rate was the decrease in the need to perform elective CABG. Emergency CABG, death and MI rates were low (1% mortality, 5% nonfatal MI) and did not change significantly with time or with investigator experience.
美国国立心肺血液研究所经皮腔内冠状动脉血管成形术(PTCA)注册中心收集了1977年9月至1981年9月期间在105个临床中心进行的3101例PTCA手术的临床数据。为了研究从引入这种新的血管重建疗法到早期应用过程中的“学习曲线”,按历年情况并根据研究者的经验对成功率和并发症发生率进行了检查。成功率逐年提高,从1979年的54%提高到1981年的66%。病例数少于50例的研究者的成功率为55%。在一位研究者完成150例手术后,成功率为77%。成功率的提高主要是导管穿过狭窄部位能力显著提高的结果,这是经验和设备改进所致。PTCA的患者选择依据性别、年龄、既往冠状动脉搭桥术(CABG)史、病变冠状动脉数量以及随时间推移稳定的加拿大心脏功能分级。成功率的提高反映在择期CABG需求的减少上。急诊CABG、死亡率和心肌梗死(MI)发生率较低(死亡率1%,非致命性MI 5%),且未随时间或研究者经验发生显著变化。