Brohet C R, Robert A, Derwael C, Fesler R, Stijns M, Vliers A, Braasseur L A
Circulation. 1984 Aug;70(2):255-62. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.70.2.255.
Statistical multivariate and conventional deterministic methods of computerized interpretation of the electrocardiogram (ECG) were compared in the analysis of 1711 pediatric orthogonal ECGs validated by nonelectrocardiographic criteria on the basis of clinical and anatomic diagnoses. Among 642 children catheterized for the evaluation of congenital heart disease, there were 140 patients with left ventricular hypertrophy, 299 with right ventricular hypertrophy, and 203 with biventricular hypertrophy. A group of 1069 obviously healthy school children was studied as a control. The overall accuracy of multigroup ECG diagnosis was 85% and 79% for the statistical and deterministic methods, respectively. The diagnostic performances of both methods expressed in terms of sensitivity and predictive value were the highest for normal children and those with right ventricular hypertrophy and lowest for children with biventricular hypertrophy. The statistical method was more sensitive in the diagnosis of left ventricular hypertrophy (74% vs 64%), right ventricular hypertrophy (86% vs 83%), and biventricular hypertrophy (62% vs 50%). Mutual agreement for a correct diagnosis by the two methods was 83% for normal children and 82% for those with right ventricular hypertrophy but only 61% for children with left ventricular hypertrophy and 39% for those with biventricular hypertrophy. In conclusion, better classification results are obtained with statistical multivariate techniques as compared with conventional deterministic analysis, but both methods of ECG interpretation are complementary and their combination in the same electrocardiographic computer program can improve diagnostic accuracy.
在对1711份小儿正交心电图进行分析时,比较了统计多变量和传统确定性计算机化心电图(ECG)解读方法,这些心电图根据临床和解剖诊断,经非心电图标准验证。在642例因先天性心脏病评估而接受导管检查的儿童中,有140例左心室肥厚患者,299例右心室肥厚患者,203例双心室肥厚患者。对一组1069名明显健康的学童进行了研究作为对照。统计方法和确定性方法对多组心电图诊断的总体准确率分别为85%和79%。两种方法以敏感性和预测值表示的诊断性能,对于正常儿童和右心室肥厚儿童最高,对于双心室肥厚儿童最低。统计方法在诊断左心室肥厚(74%对64%)、右心室肥厚(86%对83%)和双心室肥厚(62%对50%)方面更敏感。两种方法对正确诊断的相互一致性,正常儿童为83%,右心室肥厚儿童为82%,但左心室肥厚儿童仅为61%,双心室肥厚儿童为39%。总之,与传统确定性分析相比,统计多变量技术可获得更好的分类结果,但两种心电图解读方法是互补的,将它们结合在同一个心电图计算机程序中可提高诊断准确性。