Jones J G
Postgrad Med J. 1983;59 Suppl 1:72-7.
The respiratory effects of the new analgesic, meptazinol, were compared with a placebo and with equianalgesic doses of morphine and pentazocine and with diazepam in a double-blind crossover trial in seven healthy volunteers. No significant change in the ventilatory response to rebreathing carbon dioxide was observed after meptazinol or placebo but morphine, pentazocine and diazepam depressed the slope of the ventilatory response (-30.0%, -31.6% and -50.0% respectively, P less than 0.02). End-tidal carbon dioxide tension (PE',CO2) breathing air increased significantly following all three analgesic drugs but not after diazepam. However, the increase in PE',CO2 after meptazinol (0.22 kPa averaged over 3.5 hr) was significantly less than that following morphine (0.40 kPa, P less than 0.05) and pentazocine (0.59 kPa, P less than 0.01). While breathing with a resistive inspiratory load of 8 kPa/l/sec, PE',CO2 increased significantly (P less than 0.05) following all three analgesics but not diazepam. The increase in PE', CO2 after meptazinol was then the same as that after morphine (0.51 kPa averaged over 3.5 hr). The increase following pentazocine (0.80 kPa) was significantly greater than that after both morphine and meptazinol (P less than 0.02). In a preliminary study of pain relief following cholecystectomy there was no significant difference in the analgesic effect of meptazinol compared to morphine, both drugs being given by continuous infusion. More of the patients given morphine had apnoeic periods, although the difference between the groups was not significant.
在一项针对7名健康志愿者的双盲交叉试验中,将新型镇痛药美普他酚的呼吸效应与安慰剂、等效镇痛剂量的吗啡和喷他佐辛以及地西泮进行了比较。服用美普他酚或安慰剂后,对重复呼吸二氧化碳的通气反应未观察到显著变化,但吗啡、喷他佐辛和地西泮降低了通气反应的斜率(分别为-30.0%、-31.6%和-50.0%,P<0.02)。三种镇痛药给药后,呼气末二氧化碳分压(PE',CO2)在呼吸空气时均显著升高,但地西泮给药后未升高。然而,美普他酚给药后PE',CO2的升高(3.5小时内平均为0.22kPa)显著低于吗啡给药后(0.40kPa,P<0.05)和喷他佐辛给药后(0.59kPa,P<0.01)。当以8kPa/l/秒的吸气阻力负荷呼吸时,三种镇痛药给药后PE',CO2均显著升高(P<0.05),但地西泮给药后未升高。美普他酚给药后PE',CO2的升高与吗啡给药后相同(3.5小时内平均为0.51kPa)。喷他佐辛给药后PE',CO2的升高(0.80kPa)显著高于吗啡和美普他酚给药后(P<0.02)。在一项关于胆囊切除术后疼痛缓解的初步研究中,美普他酚与吗啡的镇痛效果无显著差异,两种药物均通过持续输注给药。接受吗啡治疗的患者呼吸暂停期更多,尽管两组之间的差异不显著。