Smith D M, Haupt B J
Public Health Rep. 1983 Sep-Oct;98(5):457-66.
Are research and training programs in pediatrics, internal medicine, and obstetrics and gynecology (OB-GYN) comprehensive enough to give trainees proficiency in primary care? Controversy exists about which subject areas should be added to the training schema to make them more applicable in primary care. One approach to this controversy is to use the most frequent of serious patient problems that are outside these disciplines as feedback into the process of selecting areas for more comprehensive training. In this study, patients' serious problems were defined as those requiring hospitalization. Diagnoses from the National Hospital Discharge Survey were grouped into categories of morbidity by age and sex. The most frequent categories outside the three disciplines were identified. For pediatrics these problems were trauma, mental disorders, and unintended pregnancy; for internal medicine, trauma, mental and gynecologic disorders, and unintended pregnancy; for OB-GYN, trauma and mental, cardiovascular, pulmonary, gastrointestinal, and arthritic disorders. Since primary care is largely ambulatory care, the next step in the resolution of the controversy would be to define the competency level needed for the prevention, early recognition, and early management of these disorders in the ambulatory care setting. Once defined, competency levels can be examined among trainees in the three specialties, and areas where competency is found inadequate can be emphasized. Although hospitalization data are not the only logical criteria for choosing areas for emphasis, these feedback data offer a method of integrating patients' most frequent severe problems into the selection process.
儿科学、内科学以及妇产科学(妇产科)的研究与培训项目是否足够全面,能让受训人员精通初级保健?对于应在培训方案中增加哪些学科领域,以使这些项目在初级保健中更具适用性,存在争议。解决这一争议的一种方法是,将这些学科之外最常见的严重患者问题作为反馈,纳入选择更全面培训领域的过程。在本研究中,患者的严重问题被定义为需要住院治疗的问题。来自《国家医院出院调查》的诊断结果按年龄和性别分组为发病类别。确定了这三个学科之外最常见的类别。对于儿科学而言,这些问题是创伤、精神障碍和意外怀孕;对于内科学来说,是创伤、精神和妇科疾病以及意外怀孕;对于妇产科而言,是创伤和精神、心血管、肺部、胃肠道及关节炎疾病。由于初级保健主要是门诊护理,解决这一争议的下一步将是确定在门诊护理环境中预防、早期识别和早期管理这些疾病所需的能力水平。一旦确定,就可以在这三个专业的受训人员中检查能力水平,并强调能力不足的领域。虽然住院数据并非选择重点领域的唯一合理标准,但这些反馈数据提供了一种将患者最常出现的严重问题纳入选择过程的方法。