Gordon D J, Probstfield J L, Rubenstein C, Bremner W F, Leon A S, Karon J M, Third J, Bryan H, Schwartz L, Insull W
Am J Epidemiol. 1984 Aug;120(2):210-24. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a113883.
The association of established coronary risk factors with submaximal graded treadmill exercise test performance was examined in 6,850 asymptomatic, white 34--59-year-old hypercholesterolemic men screened between 1973 and 1976 at 12 North American Lipid Research Clinics for participation in their Coronary Primary Prevention Trial. The prevalence of ischemic electrocardiographic responses (greater than or equal to 1 mm S-T segment depression) was 8.6%. The Cox proportional hazards method was adapted so as to take into account the level of exercise at which ischemic responses occurred and to which subjects without ischemic responses were exposed. The results were compared with those obtained by standard logistic regression. In both models, age, blood pressure, plasma cholesterol, and (inversely) plasma high-density lipoprotein cholesterol and alcohol consumption were significant independent predictors of an ischemic response to exercise. Surprisingly, ischemic responses were less frequent in smokers than in nonsmokers. However, when the proportional hazards method was used, cigarette smoking was weakly but significantly (p less than 0.01) predictive of an ischemic response on the treadmill. Results from this model differed from those of the logistic model because the former takes into account the reduced exercise capacity of smokers, which renders them less likely to reach workloads sufficient to induce myocardial ischemia. The proportional hazards model similarly demonstrated a possible beneficial effect of habitual physical activity which was not apparent in the logistic model. Quetelet index and plasma triglyceride were only weakly associated with the probability of an ischemic response, and did not contribute significantly to either model.
在1973年至1976年期间,对北美12家脂质研究诊所筛选出的6850名无症状、年龄在34至59岁之间的白人高胆固醇血症男性进行了研究,以考察已确定的冠状动脉危险因素与次极量分级平板运动试验表现之间的关联。这些男性参与了他们的冠状动脉一级预防试验。缺血性心电图反应(S-T段压低大于或等于1毫米)的患病率为8.6%。采用Cox比例风险法,以考虑缺血反应发生时的运动水平以及无缺血反应的受试者所达到的运动水平。将结果与通过标准逻辑回归获得的结果进行比较。在这两种模型中,年龄、血压、血浆胆固醇以及(与之呈负相关的)血浆高密度脂蛋白胆固醇和饮酒量都是运动缺血反应的显著独立预测因素。令人惊讶的是,吸烟者的缺血反应比不吸烟者少。然而,当使用比例风险法时,吸烟对平板运动时的缺血反应有微弱但显著(p<0.01)的预测作用。该模型的结果与逻辑模型的结果不同,因为前者考虑到了吸烟者运动能力的降低,这使得他们不太可能达到足以诱发心肌缺血的工作量。比例风险模型同样显示出习惯性体力活动可能具有的有益作用,这在逻辑模型中并不明显。体重指数和血浆甘油三酯与缺血反应的可能性仅存在微弱关联,对两种模型均无显著贡献。