Elasmobranch oculomotor organization: anatomical and theoretical aspects of the phylogenetic development of vestibulo-oculomotor connectivity.

The oculomotor organization of two elasmobranch species, smooth dogfish (Mustelus canis) and little skate (Raja erinacea), was studied by investigating the extraocular muscle apparatus and the oculomotor motoneuron distribution. The macroscopic appearance of the eye muscles was similar to any lateral-eyed vertebrate species (e.g., goldfish, rabbit). The size of extraocular muscles was expressed by counting single muscle fibers and comparing cross-sectional areas of the extraocular muscles. There were significant differences in the number of fibers in the six extraocular muscles in dogfish, but not in skate. Fiber sizes varied considerably; thus, the number of fibers did not relate to cross-sectional areas. In the dogfish, no one pair of agonist-antagonist extraocular muscles was larger than the others, suggesting that there was no preference for eye movements in a particular plane of space. However, the lateral rectus was more than twice the size of most of the other muscles. In the skate, cross-sectional areas of the horizontal eye muscles were smaller than those of the vertical eye movers. This may indicate a reduced utilization of horizontal eye muscles, which may reflect the bottom-dwelling habitat and mode of locomotion of the skate. The distribution of the extraocular motoneurons was determined by injecting horseradish peroxidase (HRP) into single eye muscles. Medial rectus, superior rectus, and superior oblique motoneuron populations were located contralateral to their respective muscles. Lateral rectus, inferior rectus, and inferior oblique motoneurons were located ipsilateral to their muscles. This distribution is in contrast to almost all other vertebrates studied thus far, where medial rectus motoneurons are located ipsilateral to the muscle which they innervate. The oculomotor arrangement in elasmobranchs is likely to have consequences for the circuitry responsible for the production of conjugate compensatory eye movements in the horizontal plane. We hypothesize that, in contrast to other vertebrates, the basic elasmobranch vestibulo-ocular reflex pathway consists of three identically structured three-neuron-arcs connecting the three semicircular canals to their respective extraocular muscles. This innervation pattern may constitute a special feature of the elasmobranch brain or a phylogenetically older arrangement of eye movement pathways.