Packer M, Medina N, Yushak M
J Am Coll Cardiol. 1984 Nov;4(5):890-901. doi: 10.1016/s0735-1097(84)80048-0.
The hemodynamic and clinical responses to calcium channel blockade with verapamil and nifedipine were compared with those of hydralazine in 12 patients with pulmonary hypertension secondary to obliterative pulmonary vascular disease. All three drugs produced a marked and similar decrease in pulmonary vascular resistance; however, this was accompanied by a significant increase in cardiac index with hydralazine (+0.71 liter/min per m2, p less than 0.01), no change in cardiac index with nifedipine and a significant decrease in cardiac index with verapamil (-0.25 liter/min per m2, p less than 0.05). Mean pulmonary artery pressure decreased markedly with both calcium channel blocking drugs (-16.0 mm Hg with verapamil and -14.5 mm Hg with nifedipine, both p less than 0.01), but this was associated with a concomitant increase in mean right atrial pressure (+6.2 mm Hg with verapamil and +4.4 mm Hg with nifedipine, both p less than 0.01); neither variable changed after hydralazine. Hence, right ventricular performance (as reflected by right ventricular stroke work index) deteriorated during treatment with both calcium channel blocking drugs, despite the decrease in resistance to right ventricular ejection; in contrast, right ventricular stroke work index increased after hydralazine. The unfavorable hemodynamic effects of calcium channel blockade were accompanied by severe adverse clinical events, including profound hypotension and cardiogenic shock during acute drug administration and the exacerbation of right heart failure during long-term treatment. These deleterious responses to verapamil and nifedipine are likely the result of a direct depressant effect exerted by these drugs on right ventricular function independent of their pulmonary vasodilatory actions.
对12例由闭塞性肺血管疾病继发的肺动脉高压患者,比较了维拉帕米和硝苯地平钙通道阻滞剂与肼苯哒嗪的血液动力学及临床反应。所有三种药物均可使肺血管阻力显著且相似地降低;然而,肼苯哒嗪使心脏指数显著增加(+0.71升/分钟每平方米,p<0.01),硝苯地平对心脏指数无影响,维拉帕米使心脏指数显著降低(-0.25升/分钟每平方米,p<0.05)。两种钙通道阻滞剂均可使平均肺动脉压显著降低(维拉帕米降低16.0毫米汞柱,硝苯地平降低14.5毫米汞柱,p均<0.01),但这伴随着平均右心房压同时升高(维拉帕米升高6.2毫米汞柱,硝苯地平升高4.4毫米汞柱,p均<0.01);肼苯哒嗪用药后这两个变量均未改变。因此,尽管右心室射血阻力降低,但在使用两种钙通道阻滞剂治疗期间右心室功能(以右心室每搏功指数反映)仍恶化;相比之下,肼苯哒嗪用药后右心室每搏功指数增加。钙通道阻滞剂不良的血液动力学效应伴有严重不良临床事件,包括急性给药期间严重低血压和心源性休克以及长期治疗期间右心衰竭加重。对维拉帕米和硝苯地平的这些有害反应可能是这些药物对右心室功能产生直接抑制作用的结果,与它们的肺血管舒张作用无关。