Friedman T L
J Am Acad Psychoanal. 1978 Apr;6(2):175-92. doi: 10.1521/jaap.1.1978.6.2.175.
It is difficult to apply Piaget's theory to psychotherapy because the place of affect in it is ambiguous. When the alternatives are considered, it seems most consistent with Piaget's ideas to regard both cognitive and affective phenomena as problem-solving organizations. Piaget's remarkable discoveries in the cognitive sphere are a consequence of the easy access in that sphere to the kind of problems that need solving, and the phasic development of solutions. But the nature of the problems to be solved or the values to be guarded by a patient in psychotherapy are not knowable independently of the patient's actual behavior. In one respect all that is left from Piaget's approach for psychotherapy generally is the truism that therapy fosters differentiation and integration. However, even if we cannot frame a peculiarly Piagetian paradigm of psychotherapy, Piaget is valuable in posing a subsidiary question, namely, what in therapy fosters problem-solving activity. A reading of Piaget suggests that a patient learns by acting on his therapist and tacitly interpreting the results of his actions, that difficulties in therapy are the material from which therapy proceeds, and that in order to grasp the situation of the patient, the therapist himself may need to act on him and not just think about him. An implied lesson for training would be that supervision should instill a professional identity that is reinforced rather than challenged by therapy difficulties, and does not rely solely on theoretical categorizing.
将皮亚杰的理论应用于心理治疗是困难的,因为情感在该理论中的地位不明确。当考虑各种可能性时,将认知现象和情感现象都视为解决问题的组织,这似乎最符合皮亚杰的观点。皮亚杰在认知领域的卓越发现,是因为在该领域容易接触到需要解决的问题类型以及解决方案的阶段性发展。但是,心理治疗中患者要解决的问题的性质或要维护的价值观,不能独立于患者的实际行为而得知。从一个方面来看,皮亚杰的方法留给心理治疗的普遍内容,只是一个不言而喻的道理,即治疗促进分化和整合。然而,即使我们无法构建一个独特的皮亚杰式心理治疗范式,皮亚杰在提出一个辅助性问题方面也很有价值,即治疗中是什么促进了解决问题的活动。阅读皮亚杰的著作可以看出,患者通过对治疗师采取行动并默契地解释其行动结果来学习,治疗中的困难是治疗得以推进的素材,而且为了理解患者的情况,治疗师自己可能需要对患者采取行动,而不仅仅是思考患者。对培训的一个隐含教训是,督导应该灌输一种专业身份,这种身份会因治疗困难而得到强化而非受到挑战,并且不单纯依赖理论分类。