Goutallier D, Hernigou P
Rev Rhum Mal Osteoartic. 1984 Jul-Sep;51(7-8):399-404.
The results of 52 Lotus unicompartmental knee implants with a follow up time exceeding 5 years are analysed. Forty-one prostheses with a mean follow-up of 6.5 years have given very good or good relief of pain. In almost all cases, flexion range exceeds 90 degrees and the preoperative motion has been most often clearly improved. Except for those due to prosthesis infection, all the poor and fair results in terms of pain, are explained by mechanical causes i.e. persistence of a frontal instability, loosening of the tibial component (2 cases) or narrowing of the nonprosthetic femorotibial space (11 cases). The latter is not related to the presence of any radiological chondrocalcinosis. These poor anatomical and clinical results appear to be preventable by a correct operative technique. In particular, the complete correction, by the prosthesis, or the angular deformity which has caused the lateral knee OA must be avoided. This is in contrast to what must be done in osteotomies. Unicompartmental prostheses thus have to stay in stress so that their long term future is uncertain. In the surgical management of lateral knee OA, these prostheses are not to be preferred to correction of frontal angular deformity by osteotomy, except in the elderly, when deformity cannot be completely corrected. Unicompartmental prostheses are particularly indicated in unstable knees in which osteotomies are known to be difficult to perform correctly.
对52例随访时间超过5年的莲花单髁膝关节置换术的结果进行了分析。41例平均随访6.5年的假体疼痛缓解情况非常好或良好。在几乎所有病例中,屈曲范围超过90度,术前活动度大多明显改善。除假体感染导致的情况外,所有疼痛方面结果为差和中等的情况均由机械原因解释,即存在额状面不稳定、胫骨部件松动(2例)或非假体股骨胫间隙变窄(11例)。后者与任何放射学软骨钙质沉着症的存在无关。这些解剖和临床结果差的情况似乎可通过正确的手术技术预防。特别是,必须避免假体完全矫正导致外侧膝骨关节炎的角畸形。这与截骨术中必须做的事情相反。单髁假体因此必须承受应力,所以其长期前景不确定。在外侧膝骨关节炎的手术治疗中,除了在老年人中畸形无法完全矫正的情况外,这些假体并不比通过截骨矫正额状角畸形更可取。单髁假体特别适用于已知难以正确进行截骨术的不稳定膝关节。