Griffith J
Community Ment Health J. 1984 Fall;20(3):182-201. doi: 10.1007/BF00808106.
Accumulating evidence from studies investigating the role naturally-occurring emotional support networks play in remediating psychological distress strongly suggests that such networks buffer personal distress and lessen the need for formal mental health care. Research findings also suggest that reliance on emotional support networks varies across ethnic groups. The present study compared emotional support network characteristics of Anglo-Americans to those of Mexican Americans, in addition to examining the relationship between the reliance on specific support providers and psychopathological symptoms for Anglo- and Mexican Americans. Randomly selected adult Anglo- and Mexican Americans (n = 515) living in one of three suburban communities in Southern California provided responses to a standardized measure of psychological impairment and named those persons on whom they depended in time of personal problems. Both Anglo- and English speaking Mexican American (ES MA) respondents reported significantly larger networks and more cumulative contact and reciprocity with network members than did Spanish-speaking Mexican Americans (SS MA) respondents. Anglos and ES MAs named significantly more friends and neighbors as emotional support providers than did SS MAs. SS MAs, on the other hand, more often depended on extended kin and spouses than did the other two subgroups. Professional caregivers accounted for a very small proportion of responses across the subgroups. The number of friends and neighbors as support providers was significantly and positively correlated with problems of social relations in only the SS MA subgroup. Implications of results for community mental health direct and indirect service components are discussed.
越来越多的研究证据表明,自然形成的情感支持网络在缓解心理困扰方面发挥着作用,这强烈暗示了此类网络能缓冲个人困扰,并减少对正规心理健康护理的需求。研究结果还表明,不同种族群体对情感支持网络的依赖程度有所不同。本研究将英裔美国人与墨西哥裔美国人的情感支持网络特征进行了比较,此外还考察了英裔和墨西哥裔美国人对特定支持提供者的依赖与心理病理症状之间的关系。随机选取居住在南加州三个郊区社区之一的成年英裔和墨西哥裔美国人(n = 515),让他们对一项心理损伤的标准化测量做出回应,并说出在个人问题发生时他们所依赖的人。与说西班牙语的墨西哥裔美国人(SS MA)受访者相比,英裔和说英语的墨西哥裔美国人(ES MA)受访者报告的网络规模显著更大,与网络成员的累计接触和互惠也更多。英裔和ES MA受访者提到的作为情感支持提供者的朋友和邻居显著多于SS MA受访者。另一方面,与其他两个亚组相比,SS MA受访者更常依赖远亲及配偶。在所有亚组中,专业护理人员在回应中所占比例非常小。仅在SS MA亚组中,作为支持提供者的朋友和邻居的数量与社会关系问题显著正相关。文中讨论了研究结果对社区心理健康直接和间接服务组成部分的启示。