Enokido H, Torii H, Ainoda N, Hanyu T, Omori S
No To Shinkei. 1984 Sep;36(9):895-902.
So called transcortical motor aphasia (TCMA) is frequently subdivided, because the clinical features and the localization of the lesions are variable. The authors have been attempting to classify TCMA into three types according to the distribution of the lesions, such as Type F 1, Type F 2 and Type F 3. Case 1 N.S. belongs to Type F 1 showing the clinical features of TCMA with bleeding in the territory of the left anterior cerebral artery. Case 2 M.E. belongs to Type F 2 (published case). This case is similar to Luria's dynamic aphasia in its clinical features and results from the lesions including the posterior parts of left middle frontal gyrus. Case 3 N.T. belongs to Type F 3 who recovered from typical Broca aphasia after language training for four years. The case is similar to Goldstein's Type 1 of TCMA in its clinical features. These three cases are compared with regard to the fundamental bases of spontaneous speech disturbance. The items of comparison are as follows; the volume of speech production and the the time taken to start speech, word fluency test, cue effects necessary for the success of sentence constructions grammatical ability. The results are summerized in Table 2. Type F1 shows the most conspicuous defect of spontaneous speech, but no disturbance in grammatical ability. And when the top word of a sentence (a subject word) is given by the examiner, the patient can construct a structurally correct sentence. These findings imply that the spontaneous speech disturbance of Type F 1 is due to a defect of the starting mechanism of speech.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
所谓的经皮质运动性失语(TCMA)常被细分,因为其临床特征和病变定位存在差异。作者一直试图根据病变分布将TCMA分为三种类型,如F1型、F2型和F3型。病例1 N.S.属于F1型,表现为经皮质运动性失语的临床特征,左侧大脑前动脉供血区出血。病例2 M.E.属于F2型(已发表病例)。该病例在临床特征上与鲁利亚的动态失语相似,由包括左额中回后部在内的病变引起。病例3 N.T.属于F3型,经过四年语言训练后从典型的布罗卡失语恢复。该病例在临床特征上与戈尔茨坦的TCMA 1型相似。对这三个病例在自发言语障碍的基本基础方面进行了比较。比较项目如下:言语产生量和开始言语所需时间、单词流畅性测试、句子构建成功所需的提示效应、语法能力。结果总结在表2中。F1型表现出自发言语最明显的缺陷,但语法能力无障碍。当考官给出句子的首词(主语词)时,患者能够构建结构正确的句子。这些发现表明F1型的自发言语障碍是由于言语启动机制的缺陷。(摘要截短于250词)