Nigri A, Martuscelli E, Mangieri E, Voci P, Danesi A, Sardella R, Feroci L, Reale A
Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn. 1984;10(6):613-8. doi: 10.1002/ccd.1810100614.
In 15 patients (group 1) with isolated mitral stenosis and in 14 patients (group 2) with isolated aortic stenosis the stenotic valve areas were calculated according to: A) Gorlin's formula; B) Hakki's simplified formula, using mean mitral gradient by planimetry or peak-to-peak aortic gradient; C) the three-point simplified formula, using mean gradient calculated by the three-point method for both mitral and aortic valve. The three-point method is definitely easier to use than planimetry. The values (mean +/- SD) of mitral valve areas in group 1 patients were, respectively: 1.56 +/- 0.63 cm2; 1.56 +/- 0.55; 1.51 +/- 0.53. The values of aortic valve areas in group 2 patients were: 0.91 +/- 0.63; 0.77 +/- 0.41; 0.88 +/- 0.52. An excellent correlation was shown between the valve area calculated by Gorlin's formula and both Hakki's simplified formula and the three-point simplified formula. For aortic valve area the correlation is even better if the mean gradient by the three-point method is used instead of the peak-to-peak gradient. On the basis of the simplified formula, a nomogram was constructed which allows an immediate calculation of valve areas from cardiac output and transvalvular gradient.
在15例单纯二尖瓣狭窄患者(第1组)和14例单纯主动脉瓣狭窄患者(第2组)中,根据以下方法计算狭窄瓣膜面积:A)戈林公式;B)哈基简化公式,使用平面测量法得到的二尖瓣平均压差或峰 - 峰主动脉压差;C)三点简化公式,使用二尖瓣和主动脉瓣三点法计算的平均压差。三点法肯定比平面测量法更容易使用。第1组患者二尖瓣面积值(均值±标准差)分别为:1.56±0.63平方厘米;1.56±0.55;1.51±0.53。第2组患者主动脉瓣面积值为:0.91±0.63;0.77±0.41;0.88±0.52。戈林公式计算的瓣膜面积与哈基简化公式和三点简化公式之间显示出极好的相关性。对于主动脉瓣面积,如果使用三点法的平均压差而非峰 - 峰压差,相关性会更好。基于简化公式构建了一个列线图,可根据心输出量和跨瓣膜压差立即计算瓣膜面积。