Murphy J G, Fenichel G S, Jacobson S
Am J Emerg Med. 1984 Jul;2(4):309-14. doi: 10.1016/0735-6757(84)90125-6.
Patients with psychiatric problems present difficult treatment and dispositional decisions to physicians in general hospital emergency departments (ED). We studied the relationships between the psychosocial characteristics of patients given psychiatric diagnoses and clinical decisions made by nonpsychiatrists and psychiatrists in our ED. Decisions concerning psychiatric consultation in the ED, dispositional decisions (admission, discharge), and referral for psychiatric outpatient care for patients discharged were reviewed for 246 patients. The relationships between decisions and 13 indicators of patients' psychosocial characteristics were evaluated by use of stepwise logistic regression techniques. Psychiatric-related variables (severity of symptoms, history of psychiatric hospitalization or outpatient treatment, and psychotropic medications at entry to the ED) were associated with decisions made by both psychiatrists and nonpsychiatrists. However, nonpsychiatric variables including patient's age, "rudeness," diffuseness of medical complaints, time of day, and month of presentation also were related to decisions. Practitioners should be sensitive to social factors that affect their decisions about psychiatric patients.
综合医院急诊科的医生在治疗有精神问题的患者时,面临着艰难的治疗和处置决策。我们研究了在我们急诊科被诊断为精神疾病的患者的心理社会特征与非精神科医生和精神科医生所做临床决策之间的关系。我们回顾了246例患者在急诊科关于精神科会诊的决策、处置决策(入院、出院)以及出院患者的精神科门诊转诊情况。通过逐步逻辑回归技术评估了决策与患者心理社会特征的13项指标之间的关系。与精神科相关的变量(症状严重程度、精神科住院或门诊治疗史以及进入急诊科时的精神药物使用情况)与精神科医生和非精神科医生所做的决策均相关。然而,包括患者年龄、“粗鲁行为”、医疗主诉的分散性、就诊时间和就诊月份等非精神科变量也与决策有关。从业者应意识到影响他们对精神科患者决策的社会因素。