Zimmerman M, O'Hara M W, Corenthal C P
Health Psychol. 1984;3(1):77-81. doi: 10.1037//0278-6133.3.1.77.
One hundred and seventy postpartum women completed the Social Readjustment Rating Scale (SRRS) and the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI). The point-biserial correlation between each item on the SRRS and the BDI was calculated. The four items identified by Lehman (1978) as being symptoms rather than life events per se were more highly correlated with the BDI than the remaining items. However, the correlation between the life event scale and the BDI was not significantly lowered after these items were removed. It is concluded that while life event scales should not include such symptom-like items, the contention made by some critics of the life event literature that all research using the Holmes and Rahe instrument is undermined soley because of the inclusion of these items, may be inappropriate.
170名产后女性完成了社会再适应评定量表(SRRS)和贝克抑郁量表(BDI)。计算了SRRS上每个项目与BDI之间的点二列相关。Lehman(1978)确定为症状而非生活事件本身的四个项目与BDI的相关性高于其余项目。然而,去除这些项目后,生活事件量表与BDI之间的相关性并没有显著降低。结论是,虽然生活事件量表不应包括此类类似症状的项目,但一些生活事件文献批评者认为,所有使用Holmes和Rahe工具的研究都仅因包含这些项目而受到破坏,这种观点可能并不恰当。