Joe G W, Singh B K, Lehman W, Simpson D D, Sells S B
Int J Addict. 1983 May;18(4):523-38. doi: 10.3109/10826088309033035.
The present study examined variations in posttreatment outcomes for clients treated in the same modality but in different treatment agencies located across the United States. Three modalities were studied, represented by seven methadone maintenance (MM) programs, seven therapeutic community (TC) programs, and nine outpatient drug-free (DF) programs. Agency differences within MM and TC programs were not significantly different on posttreatment outcomes for opioid use, nonopioid use, alcohol use, productive activities, and criminality. There were significant outcome differences among the DF agencies, but they were explained by variations in the background characteristics of the particular types of clients served by each agency. In particular, these posttreatment outcome differences appeared to be related to programs treating primarily opioid addicts versus primarily nonopioid users.
本研究考察了在美国各地不同治疗机构接受相同治疗方式的患者治疗后结果的差异。研究了三种治疗方式,分别由七个美沙酮维持治疗(MM)项目、七个治疗社区(TC)项目和九个门诊戒毒(DF)项目代表。MM和TC项目内各机构在阿片类药物使用、非阿片类药物使用、酒精使用、生产活动和犯罪行为的治疗后结果方面没有显著差异。DF机构之间存在显著的结果差异,但这可以通过每个机构所服务的特定类型患者的背景特征差异来解释。特别是,这些治疗后结果的差异似乎与主要治疗阿片类成瘾者的项目和主要治疗非阿片类使用者的项目有关。