Santoro A, Schieppati G, Franchi F, Valagussa P, Monfardini S
Eur J Cancer Clin Oncol. 1983 Oct;19(10):1353-9. doi: 10.1016/0277-5379(93)90003-n.
The validity of the Durie and Salmon's clinical staging system for multiple myeloma has been tested in 81 consecutive patients studied at the Istituto Nazionale Tumori of Milan from January 1970 to June 1982. Median survival from diagnosis was 48 months for stage I, 41 months for stage II and 23 months for stage III (P = 0.02). Median survival of patients with normal renal function (A) was 35 months and of those with abnormal kidney function (B) 7 months. Almost all early deaths were observed in patients with stage III disease associated with renal failure. No statistically significant difference was found in the median survival in patients with kappa and those with lambda light chains. The analysis of survival according to the three main combinations of chemotherapy used in this study (melphalan-prednisone vs melphalan-procarbazine-prednisone vs adriamycin-prednisone) could not disclose any significant difference. Prognosis was, however, closely related to the response to combination chemotherapy: median survival was 72 months in responders, 36 months in patients with improvement and 25 months in non-responders (P less than 0.01). A lower incidence of response was obtained in patients with stage III myeloma compared to patients with stage I-II. The myeloma staging system used in this study is simple to employ and allows identification of truly comparable patient groups in the evaluation of therapeutic results. Our therapeutic results confirm the effectiveness of melphalan plus prednisone and fail to demonstrate any advantage in the administration of adriamycin as first-line therapy.
1970年1月至1982年6月期间,米兰国立肿瘤研究所对81例连续性多发性骨髓瘤患者进行研究,以检验Durie和Salmon临床分期系统的有效性。I期患者从诊断开始的中位生存期为48个月,II期为41个月,III期为23个月(P = 0.02)。肾功能正常(A)患者的中位生存期为35个月,肾功能异常(B)患者为7个月。几乎所有早期死亡病例均见于合并肾衰竭的III期疾病患者。κ轻链患者和λ轻链患者的中位生存期无统计学显著差异。根据本研究中使用的三种主要化疗联合方案(美法仑-泼尼松对比美法仑-丙卡巴肼-泼尼松对比阿霉素-泼尼松)分析生存期,未发现任何显著差异。然而,预后与联合化疗的反应密切相关:反应者的中位生存期为72个月,病情改善者为36个月,无反应者为25个月(P < 0.01)。与I-II期患者相比,III期骨髓瘤患者的反应发生率较低。本研究中使用的骨髓瘤分期系统易于应用,在评估治疗结果时能够识别真正具有可比性的患者组。我们的治疗结果证实了美法仑加泼尼松的有效性,且未显示阿霉素作为一线治疗有任何优势。