Gilbert J R, Feldman W, Siegel L S, Mills D A, Dunnett C, Stoddart G
Can Med Assoc J. 1984 Apr 1;130(7):857-61.
Since we could find no scientific basis for the 10 well-baby visits recommended in the first 2 years of life in Ontario, we carried out a randomized trial in 570 healthy, low-risk newborns to determine the efficacy and safety of decreasing the number of scheduled well-baby visits from 10 to 5. Among the 466 babies still in the trial at the end of the study period those in the 10-visit group had had a mean of 7.63 scheduled and 0.26 unscheduled well-baby visits and those in the 5-visit group a mean of 4.77 scheduled and 1.42 unscheduled well-baby visits. Reducing the recommended number of visits did not result in an increased incidence of illness or an increased prevalence of undetected abnormality, and the physical development of the babies in the two groups was almost identical. The mean scores of the two groups in assessments of mental development, maternal-child relations, maternal anxiety and parental satisfaction with health care were close. The results suggest that the recommended number of well-baby visits for healthy, low-risk newborns can be reduced to five for children of multiparas and six for children of primiparas. Any additional well-baby visits should be scheduled according to the needs and experience of the parents.
由于我们在安大略省发现,头两年建议的10次健康婴儿访视并无科学依据,因此我们对570名健康、低风险的新生儿进行了一项随机试验,以确定将预定的健康婴儿访视次数从10次减至5次的有效性和安全性。在研究期结束时仍参与试验的466名婴儿中,10次访视组的婴儿平均进行了7.63次预定访视和0.26次非预定访视,5次访视组的婴儿平均进行了4.77次预定访视和1.42次非预定访视。减少建议的访视次数并未导致疾病发病率增加或未发现异常情况的患病率增加,两组婴儿的身体发育几乎相同。两组在心理发育、母婴关系、母亲焦虑以及父母对医疗保健满意度评估中的平均得分相近。结果表明,对于健康、低风险的新生儿,多产次产妇的孩子建议的健康婴儿访视次数可减至5次,初产次产妇的孩子减至6次。任何额外的健康婴儿访视应根据父母的需求和经验安排。