Hartley R M, Liang M H, Weissman B N, Sosman J L, Katz R, Charlton J R
Arthritis Rheum. 1984 Jul;27(7):744-51. doi: 10.1002/art.1780270704.
Fifty-four patients with suspected early rheumatoid arthritis had radiographs taken of their hands and wrists in 4 views (posteroanterior [PA], oblique, reverse oblique, and Brewerton) using conventional techniques and, in the PA view, using radiographic magnification. The radiographs were "masked" and presented in random order to 2 radiologists specializing in bone and joint radiology who interpreted them for malalignment, erosions, joint space narrowing, and soft tissue swelling. The PA was the best conventional view for demonstrating malalignment, joint space narrowing, and soft tissue abnormalities; the Brewerton view was better for detecting erosive disease. Radiographic magnification was more sensitive than conventional films for evaluating erosive disease, but otherwise was no better than the conventional PA view. These results help the physician choose the radiologic technique or combination of techniques that is most likely to detect specific abnormalities.
54例疑似早期类风湿关节炎患者的双手和手腕进行了4个视角(后前位[PA]、斜位、反斜位和布鲁尔顿位)的X线片拍摄,采用传统技术,并在PA位使用X线放大技术。这些X线片进行了“遮盖”处理,并以随机顺序呈现给2位专门从事骨与关节放射学的放射科医生,他们对片子进行分析,以判断是否存在排列不齐、侵蚀、关节间隙变窄和软组织肿胀。PA位是显示排列不齐、关节间隙变窄和软组织异常的最佳传统视角;布鲁尔顿位在检测侵蚀性疾病方面表现更佳。在评估侵蚀性疾病方面,X线放大技术比传统胶片更敏感,但在其他方面并不比传统PA位更好。这些结果有助于医生选择最有可能检测到特定异常的放射学技术或技术组合。