Enzler M A, Sumner-Smith G, Waelchli-Suter C, Perren S M
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 1984 Jul-Aug(187):272-6.
To evaluate treatment of nonunions or pseudarthrosis in humans by pulsating electromagnetic fields (PEMF), the authors tested the method in four- to six-year-old beagle dogs with midshaft osteotomies of both ulnae. This type of osteotomy in dogs leads to nonunion. After surgery one foreleg of each dog was stimulated for an average of 25 days; the second foreleg served as a control. Subsequently all ulnae were harvested, radiographs were obtained, and the stiffness of the callus was mechanically tested. Thus, the reputed efficiency is not confirmed by controlled experiments on dogs. The stimulated bones were neither radiologically nor mechanically superior to the controls.
为评估脉动电磁场(PEMF)对人类骨不连或假关节的治疗效果,作者在4至6岁的比格犬双侧尺骨中段截骨上测试了该方法。犬类的这种截骨会导致骨不连。术后,每只犬的一条前肢平均接受25天的刺激;另一条前肢作为对照。随后采集所有尺骨,拍摄X光片,并对骨痂的硬度进行力学测试。因此,在犬类身上进行的对照实验并未证实该方法的所谓疗效。接受刺激的骨骼在放射学和力学方面均不比对照骨骼更优。