Hadlock F P, Park S K, Awe R J, Rivera M
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 1980 May;134(5):1015-8. doi: 10.2214/ajr.134.5.1015.
To determine the frequency of unusual chest radiographic findings in adults (older than 15 years) with pulmonary tuberculosis, charts and radiographs of 270 consecutive cases seen in a 12 month period were reviewed. Radiographic findings not typical of primary or postprimary disease (reinfection) were arbitrarily classified as unusual. The incidence of such findings (8%) was considerably lower than in several recent reports (25%, 29%). Likewise, the incidence of lower lobe tuberculosis in diabetics in this population (8.3%) was lower than in a report by Weaver (20%), and the finding of air-fluid levels in patients with cavitary disease (9%) was lower than a report by Cohen (22%). Possible explanations for these discrepancies were reviewed, including: (1) demographic characteristics, (2) the patient selection process, (3) the arbitrary nature of any system of classification of "unusual" findings, and (4) the change in the epidemiology of the disease as a result of chemotherapy and organized eradication programs. Of these, the patient selection process is probably the most significant factor in the discrepancy between the incidence of unusual findings in this series compared with those reported by others.
为确定成人(15岁以上)肺结核患者胸部X线异常表现的发生率,我们回顾了连续12个月内诊治的270例患者的病历及X线片。非典型原发性或原发性后疾病(再感染)的X线表现被随意归类为异常。此类表现的发生率(8%)显著低于近期的几份报告(25%、29%)。同样,该人群中糖尿病患者下叶肺结核的发生率(8.3%)低于韦弗报告中的发生率(20%),空洞性疾病患者气液平面的发现率(9%)低于科恩报告中的发生率(22%)。我们对这些差异的可能解释进行了回顾,包括:(1)人口统计学特征;(2)患者选择过程;(3)“异常”表现分类系统的随意性;(4)化疗和有组织的根除计划导致的疾病流行病学变化。其中,患者选择过程可能是该系列中异常表现发生率与其他报告结果存在差异的最主要因素。