Fouache Y, Rosier S P, Planeix T, Boisante L, Delescaut M F, Bardet J, Bourdarias J P
Arch Mal Coeur Vaiss. 1981 Apr;74(4):427-35.
A series of 80 patients underwent continuous electrocardiography by Holter monitoring (ECG-H) for 24 hours to detect myocardial ischaemia. Fifty five patients were not on anti anginal therapy. The results of ECG-H were compared with those of exercise electrocardiography (ECG-E) (33 cases) and coronary angiography (50 cases). The ECG-H was positive in 31 of 43 patients (72%) with clinical (5 patients) or angiographic (38 patients) signs of ischaemic heart disease. The ECG-H was negative in 11 out of 12 patients (92%) with normal coronary; angiography. The sensitivity and specificity of ECG-H (57% and 92%) were inferior to those of ECG-E (75% and 100%) in the 33 untreated patients undergoing all three investigations. Twenty five recordings were compared with the ECG-E to assess anti anginal therapy. In asymptomatic patients ECG-H showed pathological ST depression in 10 cases, the ECG-E being positive in 1 7 cases. Anginal chest pain was induced on ECG-E in 5 out of 7 cases with a positive ECG-E and negative ECG-H. The lower sensitivity of the ECG-H compared to the ECG-E is related to several factors: 1) the sensitivity of the ECG-E increases with the number of exploratory electrodes; 2) reduced levels of physical activity decrease the sensitivity; in false negative cases the heart rate on ECG-H was only 74 +/- 7% of that corresponding to the threshold of positivity of the ECG-E, compared to 97 +/- 16% of the threshold heart rate in true positives (p less than 0,001); 3) the sensitivity of the ECG-H and ECG-E depends on the severity and distribution of the coronary lesions; false negative results were commoner in single vessel disease (57%) than in double or triple vessel disease (24%) (p less than 0,01). Anginal pain during the test increased the sensitivity to 92%. The specificity of the ECG-H is partially dependent on the recognition of positional variations of the ST segment. These were observed in 10% of cases but were generally easy to distinguish by their beat-to-beat appearances. The satisfactory specificity of the ECG-H in this study is also related to the high incidence of coronary artery disease in the population under study (80%). The predictive value of a positive test (Bayes theorem) was 97%, but that of a negative test was only 41%.
80例患者接受动态心电图监测(ECG - H)24小时以检测心肌缺血。55例患者未接受抗心绞痛治疗。将ECG - H的结果与运动心电图(ECG - E)(33例)和冠状动脉造影(50例)的结果进行比较。在43例有临床(5例)或血管造影(38例)缺血性心脏病体征的患者中,31例(72%)的ECG - H呈阳性。在冠状动脉造影正常的12例患者中,11例(92%)的ECG - H呈阴性。在接受所有三项检查的33例未治疗患者中,ECG - H的敏感性和特异性(57%和92%)低于ECG - E(75%和100%)。将25份记录与ECG - E进行比较以评估抗心绞痛治疗。在无症状患者中,ECG - H显示10例有病理性ST段压低,ECG - E显示17例阳性。在ECG - E阳性而ECG - H阴性的7例患者中,有5例在ECG - E时诱发了心绞痛。与ECG - E相比,ECG - H较低的敏感性与几个因素有关:1)ECG - E的敏感性随探测电极数量增加而提高;2)体力活动水平降低会降低敏感性;在假阴性病例中,ECG - H上的心率仅为对应于ECG - E阳性阈值心率的74±7%,而在真阳性病例中为阈值心率的97±16%(p<0.001);3)ECG - H和ECG - E的敏感性取决于冠状动脉病变的严重程度和分布;单支血管病变(57%)中假阴性结果比双支或三支血管病变(24%)更常见(p<0.01)。试验期间的心绞痛使敏感性提高到92%。ECG - H的特异性部分取决于对ST段位置变化的识别。在10%的病例中观察到了这种变化,但通常通过逐搏表现很容易区分。本研究中ECG - H令人满意的特异性也与所研究人群中冠状动脉疾病的高发病率(80%)有关。阳性试验的预测值(贝叶斯定理)为97%,但阴性试验的预测值仅为41%。