Young L D, Patel M, Keeler M H
Curr Alcohol. 1981;8:175-81.
Descriptively, Alcoholism and Bipolar Affective Disorders may resemble each other. Both disorders are marked by a chronic course with periods of remission and relapse and often profound affective disturbance. Since lithium carbonate has shown a remarkable efficacy in the treatment or prophylaxis of Bipolar Affective Disorder, it would be natural to hope for some similar dramatic benefit in alcoholism. Two controlled studies have been published in English in which lithium salts showed some benefits on drinking in "depressed" patients with alcoholism. Other studies published in the literature have been less certain but cautiously positive about some anti-alcohol effects of lithium. Favorable anecdotal reports have continued to appear, and there is every indication that lithium may be prescribed quite widely in alcoholism. It is remarkable that since lithium has a very specific therapeutic effect on mania and a much less clear effect on depression that no one has previously reported on manic (or Bipolar) patients with problem drinking or alcoholism in a systematic fashion. This lack of data may perhaps result from difficulty in locating such a population. In a previous publication, two of the present authors reported little benefit on alcohol symptoms in a small number of patients with mania who they treated for 6 or more months. In the present study, we have extended this first report to a group of 20 Bipolar or manic patients with concurrent diagnosis of alcoholism or abusive drinking, all of whom were followed on lithium for not less than one year.
从描述性角度来看,酒精中毒和双相情感障碍可能彼此相似。这两种障碍的特点都是病程慢性,有缓解期和复发期,且常常伴有严重的情感障碍。由于碳酸锂在双相情感障碍的治疗或预防中已显示出显著疗效,自然而然会期望它在酒精中毒治疗中也能带来一些类似的显著益处。有两项对照研究已用英文发表,其中锂盐对患有酒精中毒的“抑郁”患者的饮酒行为显示出一些益处。文献中发表的其他研究不太确定,但对锂的一些抗酒精作用持谨慎肯定态度。有利的轶事报道不断出现,而且有各种迹象表明锂可能在酒精中毒治疗中被广泛使用。值得注意的是,由于锂对躁狂症有非常特定的治疗效果,而对抑郁症的效果则不太明确,此前没有人以系统的方式报告过有饮酒问题或酒精中毒的躁狂(或双相)患者的情况。这种数据缺失可能是由于难以找到这样的人群。在之前的一篇出版物中,本文的两位作者报告称,他们对少数接受了6个月或更长时间治疗的躁狂症患者的酒精症状几乎没有发现益处。在本研究中,我们将这第一篇报告扩展到了一组20名同时被诊断为酒精中毒或酗酒的双相或躁狂患者,所有这些患者都接受了不少于一年的锂治疗。